exist

[SMPEP]

I think there are photos of a few for sale here:

http://www.baseball-cards.com/vintag...ntic-oil.shtml

[judgejules1]

You had me excited there for a minute...
Those are actually all "right side"
Looking for a "left side," which I've heard may have Mantle on the right side? This is based on the PSA American Oil Set Listing. If it's anything like the Mantle "left side" card, it has Mays in action vs a portrait.

[SMPEP]

Oops my bad! Sorry about that. Don't collect the set. Thought it was just the full panel with both sides you were looking for.

[Exhibitman]

1968 Atlantic Oil
AL 3 Freehan
AL 4 Davis
AL 7 McCraw
AL 8 Etchebarren
NL 2 Agee
NL 5 Banks
NL 6 Fairly
NL 7 Swoboda match w/#8 win $5
NL 8 Williams

These are the prize-winners. In decades of collecting I have seen only one prize winner, a Claude Osteen.

[Bestdj777]

Originally Posted by Exhibitman

1968 Atlantic Oil
AL 3 Freehan
AL 4 Davis
AL 7 McCraw
AL 8 Etchebarren
NL 2 Agee
NL 5 Banks
NL 6 Fairly
NL 7 Swoboda match w/#8 win $5
NL 8 Williams

These are the prize-winners. In decades of collecting I have seen only one prize winner, a Claude Osteen.

I saw a Ruth on eBay a few months ago and received confirmation from a hobby buddy that the Mantle exists. I have yet to see a picture of the Mantle and am still, occasionally, working on trying to acquire that one (offered an insane amount of money for it).

[judgejules1]

Originally Posted by Bestdj777

I saw a Ruth on eBay a few months ago and received confirmation from a hobby buddy that the Mantle exists. I have yet to see a picture of the Mantle and am still, occasionally, working on trying to acquire that one (offered an insane amount of money for it).

There was a Mantle on ebay the other day, too.
Here is a picture of it.
$_103.JPG

[Bestdj777]

Originally Posted by judgejules1

There was a Mantle on ebay the other day, too.
Here is a picture of it.
Attachment 183216

There were two Mantles made. The one you pictured is the more common version (not the winner) and features Mantle in action. There is another panel out there that features a portrait of Mantle. That was the winner card for this particular issue. My understanding is that you had to match up both panels to claim the prize.

Here is a link to one of the Babe Ruth winning cards, which is currently for sale on eBay (not my auction):

http://www.ebay.com/itm/1968-America...item541a7a90c2

[judgejules1]

Thanks Adam.
Not following you entirely though - I probably don't know enough about this set though. Are you saying that the left side is the prize side? And that there is no Mays? Or that you haven't seen a left side. It's weird that there are so many "left side" Mantle's (54) and very few Mays (3) graded by PSA. Wonder why that is?