Ethical to sell 1952 Mantle PSA 8 uncracked case

[D.P.Johnson]

Originally Posted by 1952boyntoncollector

Perhaps it was Richard Cavalieri behind the listing and knew now he wont get paid.. (though all this talk about him with no response may be because he not in good health or on vacation etc)

That's not very nice of you to tease Ian that way. I mean, would you want someone to say that someone is spending money they stole from you on some extravagant vacation???

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by D.P.Johnson

That's not very nice of you to tease Ian that way. I mean, would you want someone to say that someone is spending money they stole from you on some extravagant vacation???

haha, for 1000 bucks would have to be a staycation..

[D.P.Johnson]

Originally Posted by 1952boyntoncollector

haha, for 1000 bucks would have to be a staycation..

It's all fun and games until you become a victim...

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by D.P.Johnson

It's all fun and games until you become a victim...

D.P- you said earlier 'That's not very nice of you to tease Ian that way. I mean, would you want someone to say that someone is spending money they stole from you on some extravagant vacation??? '


whos the one that brought up an 'EXTRAVAGANT vacation' I was not implying in anyway a vacation paid by Ian's funds, I was stating that he may be unavailable for many a reason.....then you try to go on a high horse and say 'its all fun and games until you are the victim?'

you were clearly joking around and teasing...and now I get the brunt of it from Ian when I was just making a point.......

[itjclarke]

Originally Posted by 1952boyntoncollector

haha, for 1000 bucks would have to be a staycation..

Guess who won't give two sh*ts if/when something bad happens to you? I'd say I'll make sure to post jokes and snide remarks at that point, but that's not really my style. I will say, you've shown a whole lot of class as a fellow board member

Clamoring for a name, clamoring for a name... then undercutting everything that's been said since the name came out. You said my comments should be taken with a grain of salt, but you should look in the mirror.

Now I think I'll go kick myself once or twice for even responding to you.

[1952boyntoncollector]

Originally Posted by itjclarke

Guess who won't give two sh*ts if/when something bad happens to you? I'd say I'll make sure to post jokes and snide remarks at that point, but that's not really my style. I will say, you've shown a whole lot of class as a fellow board member

Clamoring for a name, clamoring for a name... then undercutting everything that's been said since the name came out. You said my comments should be taken with a grain of salt, but you should look in the mirror.

Now I think I'll go kick myself once or twice for even responding to you.

eh if you look at the start of the conversation I said the guy could be on vacation or away...ANOTHER net54 member said that the guy may be on vacation with funds from the sale and was clearly joking....and you jump on my comment? Why you not jumping on that comment...


I actually hoping my comments will draw out this guy....I was also hoping his name being brought out in the open may draw him out as well.....maybe he sees that he may have an 'out' to explain he may more apt to try to say something..........I didn't try to offend you in any way.....I hope you catch this guy if what you said is true..

Plus this is a thread about the Mantle that was for sale...that I started......I do think that by me mentioning Richard's name and keeping it in the minds of people doesn't help him for future sales...I not sure how that's bad for you..