Black swamp auction schedule

[vintagecpa]

I know it is easier said than done, but they would have been better off not announcing the find and auction off a card here and there. It would have taken quite some time before collectors figured out what was happening and for the market to adjust downward. Just imagine what would happen if a similar 1914 CJ collection was found and announced.

[4815162342]

Originally Posted by vintagecpa

I know it is easier said than done, but they would have been better off not announcing the find and auction off a card here and there. It would have taken quite some time before collectors figured out what was happening and for the market to adjust downward. Just imagine what would happen if a similar 1914 CJ collection was found and announced.

There is no way they could've kept the lid on the BSF. A Gem Mint caramel Wags comes out of nowhere? Too many collectors would cry foul.

[edhans]

Originally Posted by vintagecpa

I know it is easier said than done, but they would have been better off not announcing the find and auction off a card here and there. It would have taken quite some time before collectors figured out what was happening and for the market to adjust downward. Just imagine what would happen if a similar 1914 CJ collection was found and announced.

What do you think would have happened to their reputation had they sold these without disclosing the magnitude of the find?

[bn2cardz]

I have been wondering the same. Did they ever announce a timeline? It also seems that they aren't all graded as I have seen the POP reports change on these when I have checked over a few month period.

I am also curious to know if any more miscuts/print errors will be in the lot. I would love to see the Ford that correlates with my Mack. If it exists and it shows up I would like to obtain it.

[glchen]

I believe Heritage originally sent most of the cards to PSA for grading, but later crossed many over to SGC, so hard to say how accurate the pop reports are on this now. I think they have also sold a number of copies via private sale, so not all may make it to auction.

[bn2cardz]

Originally Posted by glchen

I believe Heritage originally sent most of the cards to PSA for grading, but later crossed many over to SGC, so hard to say how accurate the pop reports are on this now.

This may make sense since some POP numbers did go down.

[gnaz01]

There's a PSA 9 Wagner on EBay that is a BSF right now.

[Jdoggs]

Would be a cool auction.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by edhans

What do you think would have happened to their reputation had they sold these without disclosing the magnitude of the find?

I believe the Consigning Family and Heritage made the decision on disclosing the find. The family was always adamant about being transparent with the find as they were in fact concerned about people making buying decisions based on what they knew (the sheer quantity) would affect collectors/buyers valuations. I think both have done a great job in liquidating it so far.