Net54baseball Vintage Group Break: 1954 Topps Set (sold out)

[cincyredlegs]

I will take two random spots.

Thanks,

Mark

[t206fix]

I will take two random spots please.

thanks,

Tony

[obcbobd]

Two spots #250 and random or both random

thanks

Bob

[brightair]

2 random spots please.
Richard D
brightair

[markf31]

Now just anxiously awaiting the announcement of the date and time for the break.

[drmondobueno]

Went to the beach for the first time in 8 years and look what I missed! Good luck everybody!

[bobbyw8469]

WOW! What a rousing success! Good luck to whomever pulls card #128! I heard he is a good one!

[stlcardsfan]

Darn the luck, I missed it. Didn't do enough cyber slacking yesterday.....

[autocentral]

Guys there is one spot left which will go to ajjohnsonsoxfan.

-Nick

[the 'stache]

Great, so people that expressed definite interest in the first thread are getting shut out of participating.

I must say this was handled rather poorly.

When the person handling the group break (Nick) says something is going to be done, people are taking them at their word (especially since he has supposedly done this sort of thing several times before), and depending on them following through on what they have said they would do. Not everybody can afford to keep the forum up all day.

Originally Posted by autocentral

Just a couple of updates!

-Leon will also be sending an email blast once the official thread is posted

Thanks,
Nick

Once the sign up thread was posted, Nick, it was your responsibility to make sure that the e-mail you told us would go out...goes out. Some of us work overnights and sleep during the day. Some of us have jobs where we cannot keep Net 54 up all day. And yet other people are unable to keep the forum up all day for different reasons. I made a point of clearly stating on the first discussion that I spend much of the day sleeping because of my disability. The prescription drugs I take every day knock me out, but if I knew when to be here, I would not miss the signup. I keep my phone right next to my bed, and whenever I receive a notification from the forum, I have a very loud ring tone that goes off. My phone was setup to receive this email that never came. Imagine my surprise when I came home from a doctor's appointment to see that the thread had not only gone up, but all the slots were filled.

We were also told there would be a thread explaining in detail how this was going to work. In every other group break I have ever participated in, including the few I have run myself, information was provided, including an exact time when the sign up sheet would be posted. People knew well in advance what was expected of them, and when they needed to be on the forum to sign up. It's like fantasy baseball or football. You want to participate? Fine. Here is how many people we need in our league. Here is the date when we must have the league filled. Here is the exact date and time of the draft. Never before have I seen a group break where it was said "well, when it happens depends on something else, in this case, when the set gets in. It might be tomorrow". Those cards weren't perishable items. You knew you'd have them in within the next few days. What should have happened is this. Once the cards were received, a post should have been made stating "the group break signup sheet will be posted at this time on this day". You should have given people a definitive time when the sign up was going to start. Randomly throwing it up at 9:30 in the morning rewarded those who happened to be online at the time, and completely excluded anybody else who wasn't looking for the thread.

Lastly, in a group break where there are only 250 slots to start with, why are you allowing people to sign up for more than one slot to begin with? The first thread about the possibility of a group break being done has 7,000 views. Did you really think you were going to have a hard time selling 250 slots at $13 or $14 each when there were going to be graded Hank Aaron, Ernie Banks, and Al Kaline rookies as part of the draw, not to mention two Ted Williams, and a plethora of other really nice cards? You have people here dropping thousands of dollars on rare 100 year old cards every day. If you didn't fill all 250 slots, then you could have opened it up to people buying more slots on a first come, first serve basis. You see, that's something that should have been included in the thread explaining how everything was going to be handled. But that never happened, either.

If there is a next time, please ...pretty please with sugar on top, don't tell people that something is going to happen if you can't guarantee it will. Don't tell people an email will be going out to tell them "hey, you have to sign up now", because when it doesn't happen, a whole lot of people who were really excited about participating (and who stated as such in the initial discussion) get left out. And make sure that the date and time of when the sign up sheet will be available is posted well in advance. Delaying the break an extra day or two to make sure your bases were covered wouldn't have harmed anything. nobody would have been mad if you'd taken more time. Because what we ended up with is something that feels very thrown together at the last minute, and a lot of people are being very disappointed.

[cubsfan-budman]

I guess I could be proven wrong about some small detail, but in the "other" thread, he said he'd be posting a sign up list on Tuesday. I thought it was handled pretty well.

Can't please everyone.

[frankbmd]

Originally Posted by the 'stache

Great, so people that expressed definite interest in the first thread are getting shut out of participating.

I must say this was handled rather poorly.

When the person handling the group break (Nick) says something is going to be done, people are taking them at their word (especially since he has supposedly done this sort of thing several times before), and depending on them following through on what they have said they would do. Not everybody can afford to keep the forum up all day.



Once the sign up thread was posted, Nick, it was your responsibility to make sure that the e-mail you told us would go out...goes out. Some of us work overnights and sleep during the day. Some of us have jobs where we cannot keep Net 54 up all day. And yet other people are unable to keep the forum up all day for different reasons. I made a point of clearly stating on the first discussion that I spend much of the day sleeping because of my disability. The prescription drugs I take every day knock me out, but if I knew when to be here, I would not miss the signup. I keep my phone right next to my bed, and whenever I receive a notification from the forum, I have a very loud ring tone that goes off. My phone was setup to receive this email that never came. Imagine my surprise when I came home from a doctor's appointment to see that the thread had not only gone up, but all the slots were filled.

We were also told there would be a thread explaining in detail how this was going to work. In every other group break I have ever participated in, including the few I have run myself, information was provided, including an exact time when the sign up sheet would be posted. People knew well in advance what was expected of them, and when they needed to be on the forum to sign up. It's like fantasy baseball or football. You want to participate? Fine. Here is how many people we need in our league. Here is the date when we must have the league filled. Here is the exact date and time of the draft. Never before have I seen a group break where it was said "well, when it happens depends on something else, in this case, when the set gets in. It might be tomorrow". Those cards weren't perishable items. You knew you'd have them in within the next few days. What should have happened is this. Once the cards were received, a post should have been made stating "the group break signup sheet will be posted at this time on this day". You should have given people a definitive time when the sign up was going to start. Randomly throwing it up at 9:30 in the morning rewarded those who happened to be online at the time, and completely excluded anybody else who wasn't looking for the thread.

Lastly, in a group break where there are only 250 slots to start with, why are you allowing people to sign up for more than one slot to begin with? The first thread about the possibility of a group break being done has 7,000 views. Did you really think you were going to have a hard time selling 250 slots at $13 or $14 each when there were going to be graded Hank Aaron, Ernie Banks, and Al Kaline rookies as part of the draw, not to mention two Ted Williams, and a plethora of other really nice cards? You have people here dropping thousands of dollars on rare 100 year old cards every day. If you didn't fill all 250 slots, then you could have opened it up to people buying more slots on a first come, first serve basis. You see, that's something that should have been included in the thread explaining how everything was going to be handled. But that never happened, either.

If there is a next time, please ...pretty please with sugar on top, don't tell people that something is going to happen if you can't guarantee it will. Don't tell people an email will be going out to tell them "hey, you have to sign up now", because when it doesn't happen, a whole lot of people who were really excited about participating (and who stated as such in the initial discussion) get left out. And make sure that the date and time of when the sign up sheet will be available is posted well in advance. Delaying the break an extra day or two to make sure your bases were covered wouldn't have harmed anything. nobody would have been mad if you'd taken more time. Because what we ended up with is something that feels very thrown together at the last minute, and a lot of people are being very disappointed.

Good Lord, Bill

You just saved $25. Congrats.

[RobertGT]

Originally Posted by the 'stache

Great, so people that expressed definite interest in the first thread are getting shut out of participating.

I must say this was handled rather poorly.

When the person handling the group break (Nick) says something is going to be done, people are taking them at their word (especially since he has supposedly done this sort of thing several times before), and depending on them following through on what they have said they would do. Not everybody can afford to keep the forum up all day.



Once the sign up thread was posted, Nick, it was your responsibility to make sure that the e-mail you told us would go out...goes out. Some of us work overnights and sleep during the day. Some of us have jobs where we cannot keep Net 54 up all day. And yet other people are unable to keep the forum up all day for different reasons. I made a point of clearly stating on the first discussion that I spend much of the day sleeping because of my disability. The prescription drugs I take every day knock me out, but if I knew when to be here, I would not miss the signup. I keep my phone right next to my bed, and whenever I receive a notification from the forum, I have a very loud ring tone that goes off. My phone was setup to receive this email that never came. Imagine my surprise when I came home from a doctor's appointment to see that the thread had not only gone up, but all the slots were filled.

We were also told there would be a thread explaining in detail how this was going to work. In every other group break I have ever participated in, including the few I have run myself, information was provided, including an exact time when the sign up sheet would be posted. People knew well in advance what was expected of them, and when they needed to be on the forum to sign up. It's like fantasy baseball or football. You want to participate? Fine. Here is how many people we need in our league. Here is the date when we must have the league filled. Here is the exact date and time of the draft. Never before have I seen a group break where it was said "well, when it happens depends on something else, in this case, when the set gets in. It might be tomorrow". Those cards weren't perishable items. You knew you'd have them in within the next few days. What should have happened is this. Once the cards were received, a post should have been made stating "the group break signup sheet will be posted at this time on this day". You should have given people a definitive time when the sign up was going to start. Randomly throwing it up at 9:30 in the morning rewarded those who happened to be online at the time, and completely excluded anybody else who wasn't looking for the thread.

Lastly, in a group break where there are only 250 slots to start with, why are you allowing people to sign up for more than one slot to begin with? The first thread about the possibility of a group break being done has 7,000 views. Did you really think you were going to have a hard time selling 250 slots at $13 or $14 each when there were going to be graded Hank Aaron, Ernie Banks, and Al Kaline rookies as part of the draw, not to mention two Ted Williams, and a plethora of other really nice cards? You have people here dropping thousands of dollars on rare 100 year old cards every day. If you didn't fill all 250 slots, then you could have opened it up to people buying more slots on a first come, first serve basis. You see, that's something that should have been included in the thread explaining how everything was going to be handled. But that never happened, either.

If there is a next time, please ...pretty please with sugar on top, don't tell people that something is going to happen if you can't guarantee it will. Don't tell people an email will be going out to tell them "hey, you have to sign up now", because when it doesn't happen, a whole lot of people who were really excited about participating (and who stated as such in the initial discussion) get left out. And make sure that the date and time of when the sign up sheet will be available is posted well in advance. Delaying the break an extra day or two to make sure your bases were covered wouldn't have harmed anything. nobody would have been mad if you'd taken more time. Because what we ended up with is something that feels very thrown together at the last minute, and a lot of people are being very disappointed.

I'm just amazed that someone would set up a ringtone next to his bed for a Net54 54 Topps set break. There is a whole beautiful world out there - you might want to explore it a little more.

I like 54 Topps too, but you have about 1 million to choose from at any given moment, and for a lot less than $13 for (likely) a VG common.

[rsdill2]

$ sent for spot 89 & 202. I'll take the Aaron and Banks, thanks.

[callou2131]

Love this. I could spend $100 and have a shot at a scrub autograph with a modern box, or spend $24 and have a 1:125 shot at an original Aaron, Williams, Robinson, banks etc.

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by callou2131

Love this. I could spend $100 and have a shot at a scrub autograph with a modern box, or spend $24 and have a 1:125 shot at an original Aaron, Williams, Robinson, banks etc.

The odds are less than that.

[callou2131]

I know I just meant of a single particular card.

[vintagetoppsguy]

Spots 146 and 185 are paid.

Thank you!

[Lordstan]

Damn. I missed out. You look away for a few seconds and poof! gone. Oh Well. Maybe next time.

[Tabe]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

The odds are less than that.

That's why I signed up Two Williams cards, Kaline, Aaron, Banks, Robinson, Mays, Snider - that's 8 really nice cards right there. So 1:31.125. I'll take those odds.

[MinnieMannyMookie1]

ZenPop paid on my behalf, so we're all good on slot No. 102. Thanks.

[tcornett]

Just sent payment for my 2 spots!

Thank You

Tim

[MinnieMannyMookie1]

Trying to complete PayPal transaction but keep getting denied ("sorry, the recipient doesn't accept payments using this payment method"). I'll keep trying.

[btcarfagno]

Sent in my donation...errrr....money.

Tom C

[ZenPop]

Originally Posted by MinnieMannyMookie1

Trying to complete PayPal transaction but keep getting denied ("sorry, the recipient doesn't accept payments using this payment method"). I'll keep trying.

This is for my friend, Richard. He had trouble w/ PayPal, so I used mine and he'll pay me back.

I added his address in the Notes section of the payment.

Cheers!
-John

[BicycleSpokes]

MinnieMannyMookie1,

FYI - I also had that error recently when trying to make a paypal payment. Changing to a different card solved it for me (i.e. despite the error message, it strangely seemed to have nothing to do with the recipient!).

[LKeeler]

Paid up

[Rich Klein]

If I received the two cards which corresponded to the numbers I was assigned it would be HOF Heinie Manush (you know no one is called Heinie anymore) as a coach and 1960 Cy Young award winner Vern Law.

I could live with that

Rich

[bobbyw8469]

Originally Posted by Rich Klein

If I received the two cards which corresponded to the numbers I was assigned it would be HOF Heinie Manush (you know no one is called Heinie anymore) as a coach and 1960 Cy Young award winner Vern Law.

I could live with that

Rich

Im excited...I cant wait.

[vintagetoppsguy]

Good luck everyone.

I have a feeling there are going to be many '54 Topps commons listed on the B/S/T and Live Auctions in the coming days.

[bobbyw8469]

Are you kidding David?!?! I'm going to keep mine as a reminder of how rotten my luck is! I might even get them graded and see if SGC will give them the notation "Net 54 Group Break"

[sam majors]

I am able to log into Ustream but have no idea what to do next!! Any simple step by step instructions for an old man new to this damn computer world? Thanks, Sam Majors

[Republicaninmass]

I would have

#75 Fred Haney
#143 Rollie Hemsley


Lets stick to the random slots please

[autocentral]

http://www.ustream.tv/broadcaster/17277780

[Shoebox]

I had family obligations that kept me from veiwing the live drawing but just saw I drew Monte Irvin and a common. Probably a little behind value wise but the entertainment value was great. Thank you Leon and Nick for your time and trouble. Definitely willing to try again.