Some rare and expensive bakery goodies......

[ctownboy]

Point of origin?

Does that mean he was the guy who printed them or he was the guy who sold the original lot?

Again, two different scenarios with the answer to each giving a different meaning to the cards. If he was the point of origin means he printed the cards then, yes, they are "not real". If point of origin means he was the seller of the lot then this means the cards very well could be authentic and "not real" means the guy didn't know what he owned.

In 1994, I bought my Star Player Candy cards from an ephemera dealer at a paper show in Louisville, KY. He wrote his asking price on the back of each card in pencil. He told me the cards were originally collected by his Father who had lived in central Michigan as a child. The dealer didn't know who produced the cards (I didn't either. It took me a half an hour looking through the big SCD price guide in my car to find the cards and know they were real).

Now, what if this dealer did NOT know where the cards came from and he had access to a price guide and knew exactly what the cards were. What if he priced 14 of them as real and priced the Buddy Myer as fake and the ONLY reason he did this was because the Myer wasn't listed in the price guide?

I bought all of the cards for what the dealer was asking and only later, when I had time to look through all of them, did I find out that the Myer was an uncatalogued card. Did I think the Myer card was fake because it was unlisted? No. That was because it looked the same as the other 14 cards and was on the same paper.

So, unless the guy you bought these cards from specifically said he or someone he knew printed these cards and that they were blatant fakes, I find it hard to believe, with all of the other evidence presented, that these cards are fake.

David

PS. I don't own any of these Herps, I have never owned any of these Herps and I have never even held one of these cards in my hand. I DO remember when they were on eBay and the conversation about them on the old board when they were listed.