How does a card w/ paper loss grade a 4?

[I Only Smoke 4 the Cards]

Originally Posted by z28jd

I have a PSA 5 Old Judge card with two dots of paper loss on the front, one about the size of a pin head, one a little smaller. Got the card from a friend who just got it graded, so I know it was legit. The funny thing is I also bought a PSA 2 at the same time and it was much nicer than the 5

OJ grades make no sense to me. The companies need to find a way to account for image quality.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[itjclarke]

Just saw this one on eBay... it's got a qualifer for being MC, but they missed a stamp on the back "55". Guess it's a 5 MC/MK.

1955 Topps Clemente 0.jpg1955 Topps Clemente 0 back, looks like MK.jpg

I have a Mays rookie that's graded PSA-5MC and a '52 Topps J Robinson that's PSA5-OC, both of which have NM or EXMT+ at worst corners/border/surface. Their only flaws are the qaulifier, but it seemed to me the grader dinged them on their numerical grades too for being OC/MC. Oh well, I bought them graded and have no interest in trying to get them bumped.