1938 Goudey Di Maggio Real or Fake?

[Eric72]

Leon,

Your offer was overly generous. I don't think the screw-down holder is worth $0.99 in that condition.

[nsaddict]

Notice the scrape below "Indian Gum" that's to cover up the word reprint. Here is a listing for one of those!

http://tinyurl.com/q6dm75j

[ksabet]

I contacted the guy and explained the reasons why this card looks off and he removed the listing and said he was going to send it in to BVG.

I am by no means an expert but listening to all the knowledge on here combined with completing this set several years back I felt compelled.

Seemed nice enough. Took my rationale unexpectedly positive.

[danmckee]

You got a better response then I did before I started this thread:

Dear r337man,

Your entitled to your opinion . However, Before you say something like that . You should first make sure your correct . Because your completely wrong .
not sure why you think your opinion matters ????

- first-class-cards

[ksabet]

He asked me why I thought that and I explained. Maybe it was being bombarded that put some sense into him. Told me he bought it in 1971 for $500 which also seemed fishy.

At least it's gone.

[danmckee]

Yes it is and thanks so much for your help! I appreciate the effort!

Have a super weekend!

Dan