Who is more forgiving on corner dings?

[brianp-beme]

Forget grading companies...I am more forgiving when it comes to corner dings, and heck, corner rounding and smunching.

Brian

[glynparson]

Psa used to be the more lenient on dings, I feel SGC has almost always been more lenient on wear. I feel that over the last year or two PSA may actually be more strict on bumps and wear. This does not mean I feel PSA is being more accurate in fact I feel many of the recent grades are too strict/harsh.

[ls7plus]

Originally Posted by glynparson

Psa used to be the more lenient on dings, I feel SGC has almost always been more lenient on wear. I feel that over the last year or two PSA may actually be more strict on bumps and wear. This does not mean I feel PSA is being more accurate in fact I feel many of the recent grades are too strict/harsh.

+1. IMHO, eye appeal will loom ever larger.

Best wishes,

Larry

[Leon]

I agree on "toss up". No doubt you can find cards to show any point of reference from both companies. Even within a grading company there can be different cards that are addressed differently.