Do these two cards look off to you?

[Sean1125]

I spoke with Brian from BMW, this does not match either of the Gehrigs he sold as authentics (it was close/same from VCP image). The card is still authentic, but definitely altered.

[Peter_Spaeth]

We need a third party grading service to authenticate slabs and flips.

[Sean1125]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

We need a third party grading service to authenticate slabs and flips.

Isn't there something like that for coins?

Someone might as well start it for cards... Maybe I can add it as a feature on my website

At this point things are being replicated so well that sellers have issues at every corner with a broad range of cards...

[ls7plus]

Thanks, David.

Each of the cards on the left in your scans seem to lack the detail of their counterparts on the right. My bet would be that a good loupe would also show a significantly different dot pattern too. Would be an interesting comparison.

Highest regards, guys,

Larry

[Sean1125]

Originally Posted by ls7plus

Thanks, David.

Each of the cards on the left in your scans seem to lack the detail of their counterparts on the right. My bet would be that a good loupe would also show a significantly different dot pattern too. Would be an interesting comparison.

Highest regards, guys,

Larry

Both cards are 100% authentic, very probably altered (trimmed). The holders are authentic. The flips are not authentic.

[EvilKing00]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

We need a third party grading service to authenticate slabs and flips.

Lol yea, then we will need a third party service to authenticate the authentication of the slab.

[Bridwell]

The Gehrig flip looks off on both Gehrigs. PSA was using a different font in the early days of the low number PSA serial numbers. It's possible the Gehrig on the right is a re-holder but the one on the left looks off to me.