Old Judge Proof?

[Joe_G.]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

It's a trimmed N173

I second . . . ah, third that motion.

Originally Posted by z28jd

Are the known N173 poses going to be listed in your next book, Jay? I have one that I haven't seen anywhere else.

John, are you saying you have an N173 that features a pose we didn't capture in the book? If so, there are already 34 poses in the Book that are currently only known in cabinet form, yours would push that to 35. Who is it?, time for show & tell.

[z28jd]

Originally Posted by Joe_G.

John, are you saying you have an N173 that features a pose we didn't capture in the book? If so, there are already 34 poses in the Book that are currently only known in cabinet form, yours would push that to 35. Who is it?, time for show & tell.

No, it's a pose I've never seen pictured or mentioned as an N173. Fred Carroll batting. No scans though, I got my two N173 cards before I had a scanner and I've never got around to scanning them. Give me time, it's only been 14 years

[Joe_G.]

Ah, I see, thanks for clearing that up. The Cartophilic listing and checklists for N173s and especially N175s are notoriously incomplete. But that doesn't change my desire to want to see your cabinets so scan them already !

[bn2cardz]

Originally Posted by Joe_G.

Ah, I see, thanks for clearing that up. The Cartophilic listing and checklists for N173s and especially N175s are notoriously incomplete. But that doesn't change my desire to want to see your cabinets so scan them already !

I would love to have the listings and checklists the Cartophilic does have for the N173, N175, and N172 cards. I have been wanting to know what year and type each pose can be found in. I can't seem to find a copy anywhere and have been looking for a while.

[z28jd]

The 1993 Sports Collectors Digest has the most complete OJ checklist that I've seen. Breaks it down into individual variations for each pose. It's 20 years old, so it is obviously missing some, but I'd say it's still at least 98% complete

http://www.amazon.com/Baseball-Card-.../dp/0873412621

[bn2cardz]

Originally Posted by z28jd

The 1993 Sports Collectors Digest has the most complete OJ checklist that I've seen. Breaks it down into individual variations for each pose. It's 20 years old, so it is obviously missing some, but I'd say it's still at least 98% complete

http://www.amazon.com/Baseball-Card-.../dp/0873412621

Thank you for the insight. I purchased a copy. I really never thought I would need an older version of the book. I always had beckett books and borrowed SCD from the library, but never knew I would have to go older to get the info I needed/wanted.

[sb1]

I bought the entire group of Omaha off of Ebay and sold them thru Lew many years ago, they are N173's with the bottoms cut off.