Is this even possible?

[brooklynbaseball]

If you read the listing, it is not Heritage auction, it is American Heritage. The card is in remarkably nice condition for one that has been around so long. I personally believe it is undoubtedly fake, and I checked on PSA's site, and they too list the card as "IMP".

[mschwade]

My bad, read the listing with my eyes, but my mind ready different words

[jdl7860]

These Artvue Type 1 HOF postcards were produced from 53-55

[bn2cardz]

Originally Posted by mschwade

He died in 48, inducted in 46. He actually was scouting in 46 so possible? Yes. However, Heritage didn't have a December auction and I checked all four December Sunday night auctions and they didn't sell a Tinker signed HOF postcard in any of the four.

Originally Posted by jdl7860

These Artvue Type 1 HOF postcards were produced from 53-56

So to sum it up:
Tinker could have signed HOF related items, BUT could not have signed this item because it was produced after his death?

I really don't know much about the HOF postcards so it is good to know when they are produced.

[mschwade]

Originally Posted by jdl7860

These Artvue Type 1 HOF postcards were produced from 53-55

Was unaware of that. Thanks.. I don't know much about the HOF postcards, just figured they were sold at the souvenir stands/stores the years someone was inducted.

[jdl7860]

The quickest way to tell on the black and white HOF postcards is the bolt holes on the plaques are empty on 1953-55. On 56 up they covered the holes.

[RichardSimon]

Originally Posted by jdl7860

These Artvue Type 1 HOF postcards were produced from 53-55

Though the printing on the back does say Albertype.

[mschwade]

Originally Posted by RichardSimon

Though the printing on the back does say Albertype.

Tinker was a Type 2 Alberttype. "Type 2 Albertype plaque postcards were produced from 1945 through 1952 and the text on the bottom of the front reads "Cooperstown, New York"."

Source: http://www.ebay.com/gds/Albertype-B-...1026384/g.html

[dgo71]

The same seller has this Grover Cleveland Alexander, which looks too good to be true. I don't know enough about his signature nor Tinker's, but I do know that B&W Plaques are highly forged and most of the real ones I've seen don't look as though they were kept in a vault for years. I'd be leary.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/GROVER-ALEXA...item4acd5f1b1b

[RichardSimon]

The Alex is terrible.

[gregr2]

Originally Posted by brooklynbaseball

If you read the listing, it is not Heritage auction, it is American Heritage. The card is in remarkably nice condition for one that has been around so long. I personally believe it is undoubtedly fake, and I checked on PSA's site, and they too list the card as "IMP".

What is "IMP"?

[RichardSimon]

Originally Posted by gregr2

What is "IMP"?

Impossible.

[HOFAUTOS]

Originally Posted by brooklynbaseball

If you read the listing, it is not Heritage auction, it is American Heritage. The card is in remarkably nice condition for one that has been around so long. I personally believe it is undoubtedly fake, and I checked on PSA's site, and they too list the card as "IMP".

It's actually Historic Auctions. The Historic Auctions of the now famed Brad Wells who was arrested and sentenced to prison for his actions in the counterfeit game used memorabilia scheme.

[brooklynbaseball]

So.... If it is "possible" he signed it, would anyone have an opinion as to the authenticity of the signature. I personally have not, and would not, bid either way but am still curious.

[mighty bombjack]

I did not like the Tinker at all when I saw it. I then saw the seller's Alexander, which is a clear fake, sealing the deal for me. Don't touch either of them.

[RichardSimon]

Both of them are fugly and not worth any bid.

[RichardSimon]

Tinker sold for around $350, Alex for around $220.
A fraction of what they would have sold for if legit.

[rjackson44]

Richard whos buying these things