Am I wrong for considering a return on this card?

[Leon]

I agree with your thought process Bill. For the record I think it's a decent looking three. That corner wear is normal aging and doesn't bother me much at all. Now, if it had a crease through his face, or something I couldn't live with, then I would do a return. I hate having returns on either end of the equation. But every now and then they are something we have to deal with. It's just part of collecting. In the long run, if you can't live with it you can still upgrade it. But if i was doing a "3" set I would be happy with it.

[bobbyw8469]

I had a guy recently return a 1961 Mickey Mantle PSA 7. I had large scans front and back of the card. In my opinion, it was one of the best looking 7's out there. He didn't think so. I agree with what someone else said - 3rd party grading was supposed to eliminate all this. Everyone wants a card that looks better than the grade. OP said he didn't like the one corner. Me, personally, I don't see it. I think the card looks good. I am glad the OP has decided to keep the card - I am sorry he don't like it. If he ever decided to sell it, I am sure he would have no problem getting his money back.

[KCRfan1]

The card looks nice to me and graded fairly at a 3. Then again, I'm not looking at my cards with loops and microscopes.

[bbcard1]

I lost interest when you said SMR.