Anyone know who this is??

[Rollingstone206]

...

[wazoo]

No way that just happens from shipping.

[Mikehealer]

I've had a couple of deals with him and from my experiences he is honest and easy to deal with. No problems at all.

[MW1]

If there was "no visible damage to the bubble mailer" as the buyer states, it is difficult to understand how a piece of the PSA holder could have broken off...but who knows?

Did you insure the card when you sent it?

[obcmac]

While the accusations are annoying...offer him the $5 reslab fee (or whatever and be done with it. I've received a number of broken slabs in the mail even on reasonable well packed cards. I don't think he's scamming you for a few dollars. But good luck!

[djrhanover]

Though I'm certainly not defending the buyer here, I have to say that this actually happened to me a few years ago. I received a PSA slabbed card by way of USPS, and when I opened the package discovered that the slab was cracked totally in half with absolutely no damage to the mailer. The card could, incredibly, be slid out of both the top and bottom halves of the slab, and then be reinserted. And there was no damage to the card, which I could hardly believe. I emailed the seller and he told me to mail the package back to him, along with the card, and he would resubmit it, along with his usual monthly submissions to PSA. I received the newly entombed card back from him about a month later. Thanks to seller Dan McKee, I was a happy buyer and a return customer. And I never forgot this gesture by him to make things right.

[bxb]

His story is plausible, and you can't prove otherwise.

Although there are several options, The path of least resistance for you is to send him the reholdering fee, or ask him to ship the card back to you for a full refund.