New Member & 1933 Goudey Ruth Raw opinions

[KCRfan1]

Welcome aboard Mike! Agreed, buying ungraded cards pose a risk, but so does buying graded from certain grading companies ( as some on this board will tell you ). What is it about the cards, that leads you to believe that the cards are not authentic?

[Tacitdeals]

Thanks for the fast replies! I thought they looked good. So the lot would be these 4 cards and a 33 goudey #92 gehrig psa 1.5. Does 1200 seem to be a fair price for the 5 cards?

[scooter729]

$1200 would be a great price for that group - the Ruth could fetch $1000+ on its own.

Be careful and hopefully it's not "too" good of a price to be true!

[g_vezina_c55]

welcome

look good for me too

[ullmandds]

price sounds too good to be true...cards look real...just make sure you're actually getting the cards shown?!

[Tao_Moko]

Originally Posted by Tacitdeals

Thanks for the fast replies! I thought they looked good. So the lot would be these 4 cards and a 33 goudey #92 gehrig psa 1.5. Does 1200 seem to be a fair price for the 5 cards?

$1200 sounds about right until you throw the Gehrig in. It's not the steal of the century but good enough to ensure you have a refund option. I'd use payment methods that will give you some security and see if you can call the seller to discuss the transaction.

[autograf]

Paypal with credit card funding...........

[vintagechris]

Originally Posted by autograf

Paypal with credit card funding...........

I agree with Tom. I wouldn't do it at all unless with cc. Deal seems a little too good to me.

[Tacitdeals]

Bumb to my thread a few weeks past. I went ahead and purchased the lot of 5 cards and received them last week. Everything looked good so I sent them off to PSA for grading. The Ruth came back PSA 1, which was expected. Just waiting on the 3 US Caramels. Update when those grades post.

[barrysloate]

That Ruth sure looks a heck of a lot nicer than a 1. Why do you think it got such a low grade?

[Tacitdeals]

Originally Posted by Tacitdeals

Bumb to my thread a few weeks past. I went ahead and purchased the lot of 5 cards and received them last week. Everything looked good so I sent them off to PSA for grading. The Ruth came back PSA 1, which was expected. Just waiting on the 3 US Caramels. Update when those grades post.

The 3 U.S. Caramels all graded PSA 2's.