The Response

[Rich Klein]

I'm not a lawyer but I did stay at a Holiday Inn Express last night.

[ullmandds]

I don't know...from the "Lebron James" type title...to the lame, BS explanation that doesn't explain anything...I find Joe's explanation to be lacking any real substance...and as stated he failed to address any legitimate concerns!

I vote for reinstatement of the original title ASAP!

[D.P.Johnson]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

I don't know...from the "Lebron James" type title...to the lame, BS explanation that doesn't explain anything...I find Joe's explanation to be lacking any real substance...and as stated he failed to address any legitimate concerns!

I vote for reinstatement of the original title ASAP!

Ditto. And, if every one else is required to have their first and last name on posts, he should have it on his...

[WhenItWasAHobby]

Just now reading the opening post, in my opinion based on the scan, the Art Shell PSA 10 was clearly overgraded based on the bottom left corner.

What's bothersome is that a person who claims to have been a professional grader should have clearly seen upon inspection with the training of a professional grader that this card was overgraded. Rather than correct the oversight with PSA, he chose to make a huge profit on the card.

As stated by many others, there were other salient issues, arguably more serious than bumps on crackouts that were never addressed, which I find rather disturbing.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by D.P.Johnson

Ditto. And, if every one else is required to have their first and last name on posts, he should have it on his...

He does (now) as I just added it as I said I would.

As far as changing anything else or stepping in, I always prefer not to. A forum member can generally edit their responses if they want to. It's part of the forum and the way it's always been.

[D.P.Johnson]

Originally Posted by Leon

He does (now) as I just added it as I said I would.

As far as changing anything else or stepping in, I always prefer not to. A forum member can generally edit their responses if they want to. It's part of the forum and the way it's always been.

Perfect. It's there for eternity (or until he cuts another deal)......

[vintagetoppsguy]

Originally Posted by JP21

...since I held up my end of the terms of the deal...

Ummm, no you did not hold up your end of the deal. You only mentioned the questionable bumps. You didn't address the card doctoring, other than to deny it. The '34 Gehrig you bought clearly had the pencil mark erased. Are you telling the board all of our eyes are deceiving us? Come on! Other cards you bought seem to have been trimmed and/or had stray print marks removed. You didn't address the obvious shill bidding and you didn't address many of the questions that other members had. You made some generic statement that doesn't mean squat.

Originally Posted by ullmandds

I vote for reinstatement of the original title ASAP!

Done

[D.P.Johnson]

Originally Posted by vintagetoppsguy

Ummm, no you did not hold up your end of the deal. You only mentioned the questionable bumps. You didn't address the card doctoring, other than to deny it. The '34 Gehrig you bought clearly had the pencil mark erased. Are you telling the board all of our eyes are deceiving us? Come on! Other cards you bought seem to have been trimmed and/or had stray print marks removed. You didn't address the obvious shill bidding and you didn't address many of the questions that other members had. You made some generic statement that doesn't mean squat.



Done

Beautiful! He fell for it hook, line, and sinker...Rookie move "Joey"...

[auggiedoggy]

Originally Posted by rich klein

i'm not a lawyer but i did stay at a holiday inn express last night.

lol. :d