Muhammad Ali? Is this an authentic Ali? VERDICT IS IN

[Mr. Zipper]

Originally Posted by joed25

Where is the boxing expert?

Perhaps he's stranded on Autograph Planet.

[Fuddjcal]

Originally Posted by Mr. Zipper

Perhaps he's stranded on Autograph Planet.

That's what I love about that boob....complete nimrod, IMHO

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WxtW98VSegk

That's big, dumb, flaring like a pack of hemorrhoids boy on the right.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Fuddjcal

That's what I love about that boob....complete nimrod, IMHO

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WxtW98VSegk

That's big, dumb, flaring like a pack of hemorrhoids boy on the right.

3 Stooges- They just don't make slapstick like that anymore.....it's too bad.

[Duluth Eskimo]

I think it's actually good, by its such a bad signature that it is hard to know for sure. If your question is a actually, "is it worth the the risk to get a PSA or JSA letter" I would say yes depending on what it will cost you. With that being said, I do not proclaim to be an Ali expert. I have bought and sold a number of Ali items in the past as well as received earlier stuff in person from Ali. This is one of those signatures that there will be equal opinions on both sides.

[thenavarro]

Originally Posted by Duluth Eskimo

I think it's actually good, by its such a bad signature that it is hard to know for sure. If your question is a actually, "is it worth the the risk to get a PSA or JSA letter" I would say yes depending on what it will cost you. With that being said, I do not proclaim to be an Ali expert. I have bought and sold a number of Ali items in the past as well as received earlier stuff in person from Ali. This is one of those signatures that there will be equal opinions on both sides.

Thanks Jason for your opinion.

I'm not worried about a PSA or JSA letter, just trying to find out if the sig is legit or not.

[thecatspajamas]

Originally Posted by Mr. Zipper

Perhaps he's stranded on Autograph Planet.

Isn't Mueller one of the Planet guys as well?

[Mr. Zipper]

Originally Posted by thecatspajamas

Isn't Mueller one of the Planet guys as well?

Yes, he is Travis's friend.

And Travis's silence speaks volumes.

[thenavarro]

Have sent an evaluation request to Shawn from aliautos.net to take a look and render an opinion.

Shawn has always been fairly knowledgeable from what I can tell on Ali. He has co-authored a guide on Ali (and even though one of the co-authors was Koschal), Shawn has always been a straight shooter and honest in our dealings.

Mike

[Mr. Zipper]

Originally Posted by thenavarro

Have sent an evaluation request to Shawn from aliautos.net to take a look and render an opinion.

Shawn has always been fairly knowledgeable from what I can tell on Ali. He has co-authored a guide on Ali (and even though one of the co-authors was Koschal), Shawn has always been a straight shooter and honest in our dealings.

Mike

Agreed. From what I know, Sean Anderson is a credible and impartial Ali expert. I had him examine my Ali.

[thenavarro]

and the verdict is in


"Hello Mike,


Regarding: Attached image (glove)

I have looked at the listing and it is my opinion that the signature is authentic.



Additional comments

I would like to see different angles if possible. I don't think it would alter my opinion, just would like to see them.



Thank you for using the AliAutos.com Opinion Service.


Email me with any questions you may have.


Shawn Anderson
http://www.AliAutos.com"

[thenavarro]

Perhaps some scarce harmony on a boxing autograph. Was at Beckett today in Dallas, and had my Ali glove with me and got it authenticated by JSA today as well.

Now it's been passed by Todd Mueller autographs, Aliautos.com, and James Spence Authentication.

Would still be interesting to read what our resident boxing autograph expert thinks about it, as it poses a pretty difficult conundrum.

1) If he thinks it's good, I doubt he would say, because then it would mean he would have to say that a piece I have, and a piece that JSA authenticated, was actually good
2) if he thinks it's bad, I doubt he would say, because then he would have to indicate that a piece that one of his friends (Todd Mueller) sold was bad

Probably best to just stay out of it, or give a no opinion, which is his perfectly acceptable right as well.

As the world turns in the world of autograph politics.

What a GREAT hobby we have! LOL (in all seriousness, I do love the hobby)