Best story of 2013

[Cardboard Junkie]

Originally Posted by teetwoohsix

I think what he did was great.

You may be right David, about why the crowd cheered-but I like the fact that he ripped up the "approved" speech and said what he wanted to. It's his day in the sun, he worked hard to graduate, he should be allowed to give a speech without someone having to comb it over for "approval". Do they not trust the kids they teach to speak their mind without "approval"? And, what makes the person "approving" the speeches so righteous to decide what's ok and what's not?

Thanks for posting this link Steve

Sincerely, Clayton

Yes! I too think that what he did was great. In exercising the freedom to "say whatever he wants"! I sometimes feel that our "freedom of speech" is impeded by "political correctness". Dave.

[barrysloate]

Isn't the valedictorian supposed to speak about his educational experiences, his college future, his past four years of high school, or something to that effect? Isn't that the whole point of the ceremony? I'm not sure I understand what he did that was so special. What if he tore up his speech and spoke about why he thought the Yankees are going to win the pennant? Would that be a noble gesture?

[Jlighter]

Originally Posted by barrysloate

Isn't the valedictorian supposed to speak about his educational experiences, his college future, his past four years of high school, or something to that effect? Isn't that the whole point of the ceremony? I'm not sure I understand what he did that was so special. What if he tore up his speech and spoke about why he thought the Yankees are going to win the pennant? Would that be a noble gesture?

Would it be noble...probably not, I would have stood and applauded though.

I see that the Valedictorian has earned the right to talk about whatever they feel is right. At my High School three speeches were given. Valedictorian, Salutatorian and Class President. If anything I feel the onus is on the Class President to give the type of speech you describe.

I was close to getting a speech position, and thought a little about what I would say. Instead of just reciting a regurgitated speech being given at every High School across the country that most likely would have gone through one ear and out the other; I would have highlighted a particular student who didn't get the recognition they deserved.

At least one student would remember the speech.

[teetwoohsix]

Originally Posted by barrysloate

Isn't the valedictorian supposed to speak about his educational experiences, his college future, his past four years of high school, or something to that effect? Isn't that the whole point of the ceremony? I'm not sure I understand what he did that was so special. What if he tore up his speech and spoke about why he thought the Yankees are going to win the pennant? Would that be a noble gesture?

Well Barry, the noble gesture to me is the fact that he ripped up an "approved" speech and said what he really wanted to say. The crowd understood the act, and cheered for him!!! Grad's gone wild!!! lol

Sincerely, Clayton

[barrysloate]

Hi Clayton- but what he said had nothing to do with the ceremony at hand. I guess we're having a debate about the meaning of free speech. And since that's a political issue I'll bow out right here.

Have a good one.

[EvilKing00]

Originally Posted by barrysloate

Isn't the valedictorian supposed to speak about his educational experiences, his college future, his past four years of high school, or something to that effect? Isn't that the whole point of the ceremony? I'm not sure I understand what he did that was so special. What if he tore up his speech and spoke about why he thought the Yankees are going to win the pennant? Would that be a noble gesture?

yes he is supposed to talk about his educational experiences, and I think he actually did. By showing he learned all about the constitution.

[barrysloate]

Steve- if he tore up his speech and used his time to do an impression of the Three Stooges, would you respond the same way?

[Cardboard Junkie]

Did someone say three stooges?https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=agclATD-zXs:) Dave.

[sam majors]

A file was started on that young man before he was half way through tearing up the "approved" speech!

[Cardboard Junkie]

probably a pot smoker too

[teetwoohsix]

Originally Posted by sam majors

A file was started on that young man before he was half way through tearing up the "approved" speech!

1984

Sincerely, Clayton

[EvilKing00]

Originally Posted by barrysloate

Steve- if he tore up his speech and used his time to do an impression of the Three Stooges, would you respond the same way?

no, lol, um as he was told by the school not to mention god what he did was about right. If they told him not to mention moe, well then our suggestion would of been perfect.