Fair shake; calling out Kirk Keith

[Leon]

Originally Posted by JoeyF1981

Leon- I posted the paypal transaction of the avengers #1 cgc 3.5 that Kirk accused me of cracking out and selling as a 5.0 or higher. This transaction shows when I sold it and as you can see in the details it states avengers #1 cgc 3.5, not 5.0 or higher

That's fine. I am not going to interfere in the thread too much, except to express my own thoughts...just like anyone else can do. I will caution everyone from posting too much personal (especially contact) info which isn't allowed. So, take out personal info from communications, and most things can be posted. I reserve the right, as usual, to take out very personal info that is posted. Members can get their point across without posting things not permitted.

[JoeyF1981]

leon- no problem. i just wanted to show the transaction to prove that I did indeed sell it and his accusation was false

[uffda51]

I thought this thread was going to be about Alan Rosen . . .

[Orioles1954]

Yay! More grown men fighting about baseball cards!

[JoeyF1981]

Originally Posted by Orioles1954

Yay! More grown men fighting about baseball cards!

lol..I wish that was all it was about. This guy has literally been following my every move for the past 2 years and accused me of everything and anything. Im calling BS on all of his lies and made up stories about me and demand proof. never seen a grown man like Kirk go to such lengths to try and rub someones name in the mud

[auggiedoggy]

Originally Posted by Orioles1954

Yay! More grown men fighting about baseball cards!

Naw! Sounds more like a defamation of character case instead. Fair enough. If you're going to make remarks about someone's character, you better be able to back it up with facts. Making accusations via an Internet forum shouldn't give someone free reign to make disparaging, unproven remarks about someone else. On the other hand, if the remarks are true and can be proven then I have no problem with a dishonest seller being "outed" to protect potential victims. Not taking sides in this because a) I don't know enough about the details and b) the originator of said disparaging remarks hasn't presented his argument yet and c) it really none of my damn business! Now if you don't mind, I'm going to get some popcorn.

Councils, are you ready? Present your cases!!!

Do you still need my name Leon since I'll be a spectator through all of this?

[batsballsbases]

Originally Posted by uffda51

I thought this thread was going to be about Alan Rosen . . .

So did I! Very upset. This is all kids stuff compared to a good Mr Mint rippin!!

[Cardboard Junkie]

Gotta admit I looked up mrmint in our member names...couldn't find it..searched old threads....I guess the talk is about somebody named kirk keith? So why the references to mrmint?
btw Joey.....did you buy an ex+ raw 54 Topps Kaline rookie from me a couple of years ago.....then claim it had a crease....and I "kickbacked" a few bucks to avoid a return and neg feedback? Maybe it wasn't you but it seemed like the modus operandi described in the other thread.
Peace, Dave.

[JoeyF1981]

Originally Posted by Cardboard Junkie

Gotta admit I looked up mrmint in our member names...couldn't find it..searched old threads....I guess the talk is about somebody named kirk keith? So why the references to mrmint?
btw Joey.....did you buy an ex+ raw 54 Topps Kaline rookie from me a couple of years ago.....then claim it had a crease....and I "kickbacked" a few bucks to avoid a return and neg feedback? Maybe it wasn't you but it seemed like the modus operandi described in the other thread.
Peace, Dave.

Sorry I shouldve referenced kirk keith. His name on the psa boards is mrmint. And no I have never bought any Al Kaline card. never collected any of his cards and dont really know anything about him. The only 54 topps cards ive bought are Hank aaron Rc's and a Ted williams #1 and #250 which was awhile ago.

[Cardboard Junkie]

Originally Posted by JoeyF1981

Sorry I shouldve referenced kirk keith. His name on the psa boards is mrmint. And no I have never bought any Al Kaline card. never collected any of his cards and dont really know anything about him. The only 54 topps cards ive bought are Hank aaron Rc's and a Ted williams #1 and #250 which was awhile ago.

Cool.......ok now let's get to the Kirk Keith Kunundrum. Kalling Kaptain Kirk!!

[Sean1125]

I wanted to get "in" then I realized this was already 14 pages deep... Time for some late night reading.

Edited to add name as per Leon's request

S34N B4551K

[slidekellyslide]

Originally Posted by Sean1125

I wanted to get "in" then I realized this was already 14 pages deep... Time for some late night reading.

Edited to add name as per Leon's request

S34N B4551K

There is an easy way to get more posts per page...click on your user name in this thread, then click on "UserCP", scroll down to "Settings and Options", click on "Edit Options"...then scroll down to "Thread Display Options"...you will see a little window that you can click on which will give you the option of up to 80 posts per page, but I'm pretty sure you can only get 40 maximum. Makes it much easier to read these long threads.

[earlywynnfan]

Someone needs to feel sorry for me. I just read the Adrian-Leaving thread from beginning to end, and jumped right into this one.

My God, I need a life!!