1941 Yankee Baseball---Let's have some FUN for a change!

[GoldenAge50s]

Ball was presented to me as a 1941. Usually a good "tell" is Johnny Sturm, who played in 124 games that yr and was never in the Majors again!

All players fit 1941 EXCEPT 1---Mel Queen--who was there in 1942-'44-'46 & '47.

So, am I correct in assuming this ball was most likely signed during Spring Training of 1941 where Mel was most likely on the field but didn't make the team? He spent 1941 w/ 3 diff Yankee farm clubs, including AA Kansas City.

[mr2686]

Originally Posted by GoldenAge50s

Ball was presented to me as a 1941. Usually a good "tell" is Johnny Sturm, who played in 124 games that yr and was never in the Majors again!

All players fit 1941 EXCEPT 1---Mel Queen--who was there in 1942-'44-'46 & '47.

So, am I correct in assuming this ball was most likely signed during Spring Training of 1941 where Mel was most likely on the field but didn't make the team? He spent 1941 w/ 3 diff Yankee farm clubs, including AA Kansas City.

I think you're correct. Can't be 42 since Sturm had already joined the service so that pretty much leaves Spring of 41.

[GoldenAge50s]

Thanks for your reply--I appreciate it.

(I very politely invited Shelly & Richard S to reply in re: to the Gomez sig possibly being clubhouse & re: any scarce or rare sigs on the ball (such as Art Fletcher, who Richard deems RARE in his recent Sales Letter) but so far they have not replied.)

[David Atkatz]

Art Fletcher's is a quite common signature--perhaps it becomes more rare when you're trying to sell one.
He had a very distinctive "A," a large lower case style with an extra surrounding loop--just as it appears on your ball.

[GoldenAge50s]

Thanks David--very interesting! What about Red Branch & Charlie Stanceau? Any idea on their scarcity?

[David Atkatz]

None at all. Sorry.

[shelly]

Originally Posted by GoldenAge50s

Thanks for your reply--I appreciate it.

(I very politely invited Shelly & Richard S to reply in re: to the Gomez sig possibly being clubhouse & re: any scarce or rare sigs on the ball (such as Art Fletcher, who Richard deems RARE in his recent Sales Letter) but so far they have not replied.)

From the looks of the ball below I will say no on the Gomez

lg.jpg

[GoldenAge50s]

No being not clubhouse or not authentic? Your Lefty Gomez looks alot different to me than my Lefty Gomez, so I think you mean "not authentic"----and Thank You for replying--just trying to help an old friend w/ good, reliable advice!!

[shelly]

Originally Posted by GoldenAge50s

No being not clubhouse or not authentic? Your Lefty Gomez looks alot different to me than my Lefty Gomez, so I think you mean "not authentic"----and Thank You for replying--just trying to help an old friend w/ good, reliable advice!!

I really have no idea what you are saying. The Lefty Gomez on your ball is not authentic. No more No less. Unless someone can show me or your friend any thing different You said lets have fun I am not,

[GoldenAge50s]

You posted---From the looks of the ball below I will say NO on the Gomez


I was just trying to understand what your NO meant! I believed MY Gomez was "clubhouse" and you do too! We are in agreement---that's fun to me!