Heritage Auction pickups from last night....

[Matthew H]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

nothing for me...seems like some pretty fair prices on rare 19th c cabinets...d304 cobb...e98 set. e99/100 near sets.

Still blows me away some BSF prices considering so many are out there!!!!

Congrats to all the winners!

Which Cabinets went for pretty fair prices? I wasn't bidding/tracking them all but I thought the ones I was looking at went at or above what I thought they would. I bid on a few... Maybe I'm a cheap-o? My limited knowledge Could be wrong... but I think 300-700 for photos of common ball players in street clothes is quite a bit. I liked the Mutrie the most, mainly because I'm used to seeing him in street clothes. It still went for more than I wanted to pay. The higher-end stuff had strong prices... In my opinion.

[Runscott]

Originally Posted by Matthew H

Which Cabinets went for pretty fair prices? I wasn't bidding/tracking them all but I thought the ones I was looking at went at or above what I thought they would. I bid on a few... Maybe I'm a cheap-o? My limited knowledge Could be wrong... but I think 300-700 for photos of common ball players in street clothes is quite a bit. I liked the Mutrie the most, mainly because I'm used to seeing him in street clothes. It still went for more than I wanted to pay. The higher-end stuff had strong prices... In my opinion.

The N173 of Kelly was an unusually nice albumen image, in my opinion. I was the underbidder, and kind of regret not going a bit higher.

I thought the 1891 Joseph Hall Giants cabinet went high. It was also weird that they thought there would be argument over the missing '1' digit at the end of 1891. Perhaps they did that in order to make it seem unique, but Lew Lipset sold one of these a while back that had the entire '1891', and also almost an inch more of the top of the mount.

The other commons might have gone high because they were probably from one of the Ewings' estate.

[RCMcKenzie]

I was able to pick up the McAleer cabinet for under the estimate. The photography on it looks just like the Just So cards to me. I will post more opinions about it when I get it.

I was the underbidder on the Pelicans team cabinet and the Pelicans Ewing. I did manage to get the "Anon" Pelican player card, I'm hoping to ID it and will post more about it later. It looks like Farmer Vaughn and Ed Cartright are on the team card as well as J Ewing and the anon player I got. Maybe the whole team card can be identified, as many n172 subjects played for the 1887 Pelicans.

[nolemmings]

That McAleer is outstanding. I bid on it, but really didn't have much to spend in this auction if I want to have a decent chance at anything in REA. I won the John Ewing New York Rembrandt. I would never have bid on it if I thought I could win the McAleer for that price, but couldn't afford both at the moment so had to settle for the one. Oh well--anyone here able to tell me whether Ewing is wearing a 1890 PL Giants uniform or a 1891 NL Giants uniform?

[big80s]

That is gorgeous, Todd! Congrats!

[CMIZ5290]

If anyone on the board bought this card, I wish they would contact me...thanks

[CW]

Great pickups, all! Really like that D304 Cobb.

My lone pickup....