Blatantly Hacked and Kudos to Rob Lifson PSA should be ashamed!

[tschock]

Originally Posted by jhs5120

Because they have been assigned a numerical grade it opens the door wide open to future fraud, deception and theft....I know REA is doing what they can to inform the buyer, but these cards should not be sold in these holders.

OK so far, you've offered 2 solutions to stop them from being sold in these holders.

1 ) REA should refuse to sell them. Fine, REA can do that, but do you honestly think no one else will sell them? Especially if the INTENT is deceive?

2 ) REA should turn them in to PSA for re-evaluation. Again, REA does not OWN the cards so they can not legally do that without buyer consent.

So the onus still falls squarely on the seller and PSA. REA can do no more than what they are already doing.

They have offered their OPINION on the cards in question, and my guess is, they would have had to get the seller's consent to even do that.

Do you have any other logical options to what REA should do?

Originally Posted by jhs5120

Someone profited on this card because they got it for a bargain at REA and flipped it months later.

Thanks for proving your option 1 won't work.

[travrosty]

Originally Posted by tschock

OK so far, you've offered 2 solutions to stop them from being sold in these holders.

1 ) REA should refuse to sell them. Fine, REA can do that, but do you honestly think no one else will sell them? Especially if the INTENT is deceive?

2 ) REA should turn them in to PSA for re-evaluation. Again, REA does not OWN the cards so they can not legally do that without buyer consent.

So the onus still falls squarely on the seller and PSA. REA can do no more than what they are already doing.

They have offered their OPINION on the cards in question, and my guess is, they would have had to get the seller's consent to even do that.

Do you have any other logical options to what REA should do?



Thanks for proving your option 1 won't work.

yeah, they can refuse to sell them if they are confident they are trimmed.

if someone else sells them, rea still did the right thing. just because the consignor can try to sell them somewhere else isnt rea's concern.

[tschock]

Originally Posted by travrosty

yeah, they can refuse to sell them if they are confident they are trimmed.

if someone else sells them, rea still did the right thing. just because the consignor can try to sell them somewhere else isnt rea's concern.

Please re-read the post and response.

Originally Posted by jhs5120

I know REA is doing what they can to inform the buyer, but these cards should not be sold in these holders.

Originally Posted by tschock

OK so far, you've offered 2 solutions to stop them from being sold in these holders.

REA refusing to sell them will not stop this, no matter how noble the (empty) gesture. Any questions?