Blatantly Hacked and Kudos to Rob Lifson PSA should be ashamed!

[vintagetoppsguy]

Originally Posted by jhs5120

So honestly, no one here has a problem with 14 trimmed cards in PSA 8 holders entering the market?

Let me ask you this. If the cards were not in PSA 8 holders and they were just selling 14 raw trimmed cards (that otherwise looked NM/MT) still describing them as trimmed, would you still have a problem?

Edited to clarify my question.

[jhs5120]

Originally Posted by Leon

Of course no one likes trimmed cards, in numerical holders, on the market.

"From the responses given, no they don't."

Originally Posted by vintagetoppsguy

Let me ask you this. If the cards were not in PSA 8 holders and they were just selling 14 raw trimmed cards (that otherwise looked NM/MT) still describing them as trimmed, would you still have a problem?

No, I have no problem with an AH selling trimmed cards (as long as they're described as trimmed. My issue is that they have been assigned a numerical grade. If they weren't graded and just appeared NM-MT I wouldn't have a problem with it, I know that there's a market for it (I have a few trimmed t206's in my personal collection).

Because they have been assigned a numerical grade it opens the door wide open to future fraud, deception and theft. There are $500 worth of cards here, but they will sell for a combined $20,000 because no one is willing to take these off the market. I know REA is doing what they can to inform the buyer, but these cards should not be sold in these holders.