What Would You Do?

[Republicaninmass]

A similar situation happened with me on ebay, a card not as described with a crease. The seller's response was "you should have looked at the scans better". Instead of arguing I just left negative feedback and got blocked from bidding on any of their future auctions. For the record, it was ebay seller Buythatcard.

[Buythatcard]

Republicaninmass. What are you talking about? I have no negs, so you could not have left it for me. I would never have responded in that way.

Get your facts right.

[Cardboard Junkie]

Originally Posted by Buythatcard

Republicaninmass. What are you talking about? I have no negs, so you could not have left it for me. I would never have responded in that way.

Get your facts right.

EEK!! BIG oops there!

[Republicaninmass]

IMO Seems to be Buythatcard on ebay has the disclaimer "Please look at the scan carefully. Scan does not always pick up the flaws" for a reason. Raw cards with creases and generic statements such as VG, EX-Mt etc and the rest are graded


Leaves negative feedback even after I offered refund 3 x. Doesn't read emails. Seller:
Member id buythatcard Sep-29-04 16:14


Reply by teddytouch (Sep-29-04 20:43):
said that 2 others, 2$ rip off shipping check toolhaus.org left neg cause I did

For the record, I was never offered a refund

Then asked for his contact info, since he left a retaliatory neg

This message is an automated reply to a contact information request made by teddytouch.
This request is related to item # 5121528945 .

Important Usage Guidelines
1. This contact information should only be used for resolving matters related to eBay. Any other use is strictly prohibited.

2. Use of this information to complete a transaction outside of eBay is not permitted. Items purchased outside of eBay are not eligible for eBay services.

Contact Information for buythatcard :

User ID: buythatcard
Name: Howard XXXXX
Company: Buythatcard
City: East Brunswick
State: NJ
Country: United States
Phone: XXXXXX
Registered Since: Friday, Nov 12, 1999 19:39:49 PST


Sorry Howard, and I almost feel for you, but karma's a bitch. Check your facts next time you call someone out. Also, thanks for the PM's they are very telling

[Buythatcard]

This is my last response to RpublicaninMass because I have better things to do than deal with a customer who tries to bring up an issue from 9 years ago which has absolutely nothing to do with this thread.

Nine years ago you bought a card from me. You found a crease that I missed. You left negative feedback as soon as you got the card before you even contacted me.

I offered you a refund. We went back and forth. Finally, the negative was removed because I sent you the refund.

So put this to rest and go focus on something more important. If you have an issue with something that happened 9 years ago, then speak to me directly instead of crying here on the board.

[Republicaninmass]

Refund never offered, and never received. Why would I bring it up from 9 years ago...worst ebay transaction I ever had. Negative was removed by me, because of your retaliatory negative was removed. Keep digging yourself deeper Howard.

I guess the moral is sometime you take it on the chin, as did I in your auction. That is certainly pertinent to your "crying" in this thread