The PSA8 Wagner... I don't get it.

[packs]

What really confuses me is the motive to cut the Wagner from the scrap sheet or full sheet it was included on originally. Wouldn't the sheet in its original state with an uncut Wagner be far more valuable than just the Wagner?

[bn2cardz]

Originally Posted by packs

What really confuses me is the motive to cut the Wagner from the scrap sheet or full sheet it was included on originally. Wouldn't the sheet in its original state with an uncut Wagner be far more valuable than just the Wagner?

+1

[auggiedoggy]

Originally Posted by packs

What really confuses me is the motive to cut the Wagner from the scrap sheet or full sheet it was included on originally. Wouldn't the sheet in its original state with an uncut Wagner be far more valuable than just the Wagner?

I'm with you on this one.

The uncut sheet would be much more valuable.

[Tabe]

Originally Posted by packs

What really confuses me is the motive to cut the Wagner from the scrap sheet or full sheet it was included on originally. Wouldn't the sheet in its original state with an uncut Wagner be far more valuable than just the Wagner?

Anybody remember how much the uncut strip with the Wagner on it sold for a year or two ago? Granted, that one was pretty beat up but that would give us an idea. Personally, I don't think the uncut would sell for much, if any, of a premium over a really nice single card example.

Originally Posted by Cardboard Junkie

Also a couple of the "raw" wags that are about, (here and there). are much nicer. Dave

I would love to see some of these "much nicer" raw Wagners if you happen to have scans.

[Cardboard Junkie]

One or two have been shown here on net 54....you will have to search though...right now I'm going surfin! Dave

[teetwoohsix]

Originally Posted by packs

What really confuses me is the motive to cut the Wagner from the scrap sheet or full sheet it was included on originally. Wouldn't the sheet in its original state with an uncut Wagner be far more valuable than just the Wagner?

That's what I've always felt. Especially in the condition the Wagner and Plank appear to be in (from the same sheet/strip/whatever it was). It's a shame.

Sincerely, Clayton

[egbeachley]

To the original poster.....I believe the PSA8 is now smaller than normal factory dimensions. Some on this Board have "slid" a good card behind it and noticed it's discernably smaller.

[packs]

What's the argument for the single card being more valuable? T206 freaks and scraps are huge right now. I couldn't even guess what an uncut sheet with Wagner and Plank on it would sell for.