Net 54 Baseball HOF

[billyb]

Scott,
This gives the fans a chance to choose who they want to see in the HOF, and I believe this board would represent the fans with justice. Great idea Scott, good luck.
Players like Jackson and Rose, banned from the HOF means that we the fans are punished to, we do not get the opportunity to see them in the HOF. Rose, in particular, a player we all watched, banned for life, means our lives too, as we wont ever be able to see him inducted.

[oldcardboard]

I like the idea,very cool. Start our own HoF from scratch? Add to exsisting? Whatever direction is taken, should be fun.

[AMBST95]

I am a fan of Paul's recommendation in post #44. It seems to be the most thought provoking and provide the most opportunity for discussion, prior to a vote. Whether we want to limit our number of votes like the current hall is another discussion, but I like this approach because it won't overwhelm with too many serious candidates on the ballot and allows us to really focus on the players up for induction. We should create a set rule for the frequency of votes and I wouldn't recommend we go any more frequent than every month if you want these votes and discussion to have meaning. At 12 votes a year, we should catch up to the Hall in Cooperstown by 2020.