Find the HOF'er

[Runscott]

Okay, maybe I'm blind. No, it was someone different - the guy I'm thinking about immediately stuck out like a sore thumb. If not for one strong identifying feature on the guy's face, I would have purchased the photo immediately.

[aquarius31]

No way on my previous guess...off by at least a few years!

[Butch7999]

Is it Lefty Grove you're seeing?

[GKreindler]

A young Al Simmons in front, second from the left?

[Bpm0014]

Guy in the suit on the right kind of looks like Bob Feller I think....

[ethicsprof]

the fella looks enough like alexander that I would've taken the leap and bought it. I think those unusual noses are pretty close---but not those chins!
all the best,
barry

[thecatspajamas]

Scott, thank you for presenting the photo this way (as a quiz). It made for some very entertaining reading, and a good example for the several folks lately who have insisted on sticking to their initial mis-identification of players in photos.

(And that's not me saying I'm better than anyone who made guesses. There's a reason I didn't post a response until after the reveal, and that's because I'm terrible with blind ID's in the first place, and would only have made a fool of myself )

[Forever Young]

This is a good thread.. 4th from right on back row..young Rogers horsnby AND the guy second from the right in the first row is Eddie Gaedel before he grew into a complete midget(not a hof I guess so I lose).

[Runscott]

Wow - I totally see the Hornsby resemblance.

Maybe I should buy this photo - one of us has to be right.