Against my better judgement, I'm finally sending this out into the wild

[Scott Garner]

Originally Posted by cjedmonton

That's my plan for HOF weekend!

Sure, there's some risk involved with this "experiment". However, if I leave clear and concise directions with the promoter, I'm confident it'll come back safe and sound.

As much as I enjoy the item as is, I'm compelled to continue on with the theme (pre-1990 MLB alum who went on to become HOFers).

I think that MAB is a quality organization, but, FWIW...

With MAB, sometimes you end up with what you ask for, sometimes you don't when you send things in for mail order. I've found that they do not always follow instructions very carefully.

Be cautious, FWIW...

[cjedmonton]

Thanks for the tip, Scott. I really only have 3 simple requests:

1. Handle with care

2. Ask the player to sign the poster where his Post It flag is.

3. Fine blue Sharpie only

So long as it comes back in one piece, I'm sure I'll be satisfied.

[Scott Garner]

Originally Posted by cjedmonton

Thanks for the tip, Scott. I really only have 3 simple requests:

1. Handle with care

2. Ask the player to sign the poster where his Post It flag is.

3. Fine blue Sharpie only

So long as it comes back in one piece, I'm sure I'll be satisfied.

I have dealt with MAB mail order perhaps 25-30 times. I have used Post It notes, etc. as well as sending a letter with pictures letting them know what I wanted in detail.

I've had items come back with signatures signed in places completely different then where the Post It notes indicated, signatures scribbled over the TOP of deceased players (thanks Roy Halladay, good job for $140-yikes!), signatures signed with the wrong color sharpie (Roy Halladay strikes again!), etc.

Just sayin', FWIW... I have never not received an item back, which is a plus.

[shelly]

I would again ask the promoter if a friend can bring the item in for you. That way you know it will done correctly. I am sure there would be many people on here to help you.

[slidekellyslide]

No way would I let that out of my sight. Good luck to you. A $40,000+ game used Mel Ott bat went missing from John Taube's booth at the National last year...you really think whoever you send this to is going to keep it under 24/7 watch?

[cjedmonton]

I completely forgot about the Ott bat fiasco. What a nightmare.

I was also informed that both players will be at The National this summer (plus several other HOFers on my wantlist).

Perhaps someone will be willing to help me out as we get closer to the date.

Thanks to all for the insight. I live in a pretty remote location (far off the regular autograph circuit at least). Otherwise, I would take this in person.

[shelly]

Where do you live. I am sorry to ask that but I bet someone on this site might be closer than you think.