overgrading

[conor912]

Originally Posted by travrosty

who is going to turn in their card for overgrading, unless they bought it for the higher price/grade and didnt think the card deserved the higher grade and would rather have the lower grade adn the cash difference?

To answer your question, yes....that is what they are saying. They are saying if you prefer, you are welcome to send it in and take a downgrade in addition to compensation. However, from what I hear, that compensation only comes in the form of free submittions and not cash. I think it's safe to say that most guys would just unload the overgraded card on some other guy via eBay to get their money out of it, buts that's just my opinion.

[aaroncc]

I have sent back a small group of N302's to SGC. I thought they were trimmed and planned on selling them. They reviewed the cards and explained to me why they gave them numerical grades.

[smtjoy]

I used this when I purchased an SGC 60 card on ebay and after receiving the card discovered there was a small ink mark on the back. The seller refused a refund so I sent it along with a sub I had going into SGC to have them look at it. They agree they missed the mark and downgraded the card to an SGC 20 and offered a more than fair choice of cash or even more in free submissions to make up for the grade difference. I took the subs. Very happy with the outcome.

Now I had another purchase and sent a PSA 4 I had that had 2 spots of paper loss and a stain on the back to them for review and they said the grade was deserved, really got me upset so I was forced to sell the card at a loss. Worst 4 I have ever seen.