Logorithmic Set Collecting

[Jacklitsch]

1911 Zeenut set is a 9 due to the nearly impossible Bohen.

[familytoad]

Whether fiction or fact, until Dr. Frank replies with his number...its all speculation to me

E210 York Type 2 needs a tough ranking...that's all I know.

[ValKehl]

I believe there is only one known example of the Roger Peckinpaugh card for the 1925 Holland Creameries set.

The T214 Victory Tobacco set supposedly consists of 90 subjects (as stated on the backs of these cards), but only about 60 subjects ahve been checklisted.

Would these sets be rated as 10s?
Val

[E93]

N167 Old Judge, Just So, 4 Base Hits, Kalamazoo Bats, Gypsie Queen are all 10's imho.
JimB

[egbeachley]

Originally Posted by Jacklitsch

1911 Zeenut set is a 9 due to the nearly impossible Bohen.

One sold just 6 years ago. This set gets a 7...8 at the highest.

[Jacklitsch]

Maybe I should have said "intact" Bohen. The one that sold was a cutout.



I still think its a 9.

[Matthew H]

Originally Posted by Jacklitsch

1911 Zeenut set is a 9 due to the nearly impossible Bohen.

I've heard there are more difficult years then 1911. Some years have player cards with only one known, some have cards that used to be known(lost), also period checklists with cards that haven't been found. (there were no chase cards in Zeenut)