T206 "Jumbo" Wagner Going to Auction in February

[Michael B]

I believe this is owned by John Rogers from Arkansas who does not need the money. As stated, he is probably just 'sticking his toe in the tub.'

[sb1]

Originally Posted by Michael B

I believe this is owned by John Rogers from Arkansas who does not need the money. As stated, he is probably just 'sticking his toe in the tub.'

Not so, it traded hands after that.

[Iron Horse]

lot of people out there with lots of $$$. If someone wants one then it will sell if indeed it is up for sale
Would rather own this one then the PSA8

[sdkammeyer]

Originally Posted by Iron Horse

Would rather own this one then the PSA8

I agree. Normally I stay away from qualifiers, but in this case (one of the few) I think it better to have it all spelled out right there on the slab.

Who knows ..... maybe it will sell for 3mil????

[philliesphan]

Originally Posted by sdkammeyer

I agree. Normally I stay away from qualifiers, but in this case (one of the few) I think it better to have it all spelled out right there on the slab.

Who knows ..... maybe it will sell for 3mil????

I doubt it. It's surely a fantastically nice Wagner. But my belief is that many Wagner owners and/or those with the means to purchase such a card would prefer to have a lower conditioned example that exhibited a lack of such a dramatic tilt.

[botn]

Not that any T206 Wagners have ever gotten special consideration from the grading companies but if a regular submitter sent even a common into PSA with this same cut it would be rejected for being miscut and grading fees would be refunded. The MC qualifier is supposed to be applied for atypical cuts as well but I have only seen it used for cards which are severely off center where margins are greater than 100/0. The reason PSA, more than SGC, has stayed away from holdering cards with atypical cuts is that it gives the perception the card may have been trimmed and once the card is encapsulated it can be difficult to tell.

[atx840]

Just noticed there is a tiny bit of the below card's border on lower right edge.

[g_vezina_c55]

Originally Posted by iron horse

lot of people out there with lots of $$$. If someone wants one then it will sell if indeed it is up for sale:d
would rather own this one then the psa8

x 2

[Jewish-collector]

I agree that the jumbo Wagner should command a premium. It's unique, and gives the owner piece of mind that it hasn't been worked on.

I wonder if that relatively new collector who bought the 1955 Clemente PSA 10 and other cards recently has enough interest & funds to go for this Wagner.

[g_vezina_c55]

For me, this jumbo Wagner is probably the best example ....

[teetwoohsix]

I love this Wagner card with the diamond cut & the huge bottom border. I'd actually want this particular one over some of the others (well, I'll take any of them to be honest ). It's a little more "unique".

Sincerely, Clayton

[conor912]

Whoever gets it should trim it and re-sub it for an 8

[Matt]

My guess is the auction house begged the consignor to do this as a favor to raise the profile of the auction and as Jay said, the reserve will be so high it won't sell.

[Jlighter]

Why would someone who could afford this card bid in this auction, if the reserve is in fact too high? Someone who cold afford this card, I would imagine is very busy. I don't think we can gauge value from this auction, just a low estimate.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Matt

My guess is the auction house begged the consignor to do this as a favor to raise the profile of the auction and as Jay said, the reserve will be so high it won't sell.

Unless ya'll know something the auctioneer doesn't there hasn't been a decision made concerning if there will be a reserve or not. I will guess that the card starts at about a third (around 500k) of it's probable value and won't have a reserve. There wasn't a decision made as of yesterday and mine is only a guess. There won't need to be a final decision on a reserve until game day. My guess is also that, depending on what rattles around the hobby, concerning the card until auction time, might be a deciding factor on a reserve too.

Edited to add, with some more thought and a few conversations my guess for the card will be about 2mil to 2.5 mil.....

[Matt]

Nah - as I said, just a guess. It would be a smart thing to do for a new auction house to try and establish themselves as a big player.

[drc]

I don't know that it will have a reserve and I don't think there's anything wrong with it having a reserve, but do think it can be bad for an auction house's reputation to have too many big ticket items that don't meet reserve.

I'm not criticizing Goldin Auctions in this matter. Their first auction seemed to go well and had lots of high end stuff. And I can understand how an auction house would like to get a Wagner in its auction in any way it can.