Most Valuable Cards in the hobby

[ullmandds]

Just my opinion...but...in no way shape or form do those former dimitri young cards belong in this discussion!

Maybe in a thread titled "stupidest money ever paid for an otherwise common card."

[jhs5120]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

Just my opinion...but...in no way shape or form do those former dimitri young cards belong in this discussion!

Maybe in a thread titled "stupidest money ever paid for an otherwise common card."

In my opinion all of the cards in this thread have sold for stupid money.

[ullmandds]

Maybe so...but the fact that one could acquire all of the cards you mentioned at any given time for maybe 1 grand in nice vg-ex cond should disqualify them.

[jhs5120]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

Maybe so...but the fact that one could acquire all of the cards you mentioned at any given time for maybe 1 grand in nice vg-ex cond should disqualify them.

I believe that condition adds to rarity, but that's a debate for a different thread.

This isn't a thread about the rarest cards in the hobby, but the most valuable, and I hate to say it, but none of our cards hold any value past what someone is willing to pay for them thus making these cards completely valid in the discussion.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by jhs5120

I believe that condition adds to rarity, but that's a debate for a different thread.

This isn't a thread about the rarest cards in the hobby, but the most valuable, and I hate to say it, but none of our cards hold any value past what someone is willing to pay for them thus making these cards completely valid in the discussion.

Have to agree with JHS here. Even though it's not my niche, and I don't understand why people collect the way they do (but more power to them, hip hip hoorah), the original question only has to do with value-

.


"We wonder what other six cards (or card related items) would be on your list of the 10 most valuable baseball cards"



.
.

[ullmandds]

blah blah blah! is everyone on this board now a lawyer...reading everything so literally?! I stand by my opinions...and I'm sure the thread starter would agree!

[Jaybird]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

blah blah blah! is everyone on this board now a lawyer...reading everything so literally?! I stand by my opinions...and I'm sure the thread starter would agree!

[bn2cardz]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

blah blah blah! is everyone on this board now a lawyer...reading everything so literally?! I stand by my opinions...and I'm sure the thread starter would agree!

I haven't given my input since most cards I would mention have already brought up. I did want to add, though, that I do agree with ULLMAN. I took the discussion meaning that no matter what condition you find that particular card in, would it be bring more money than other cards. For instance the t206 Wagner always breaks the $100,000, even when the sides and top are cut off.

So I think the question is grade for grade what is the most valuable. Since most of the cards previously discussed will NEVER be Gem Mint, we have to bring the other cards down to their level and assume the cards are all in VG condition or worse.

[irishdenny]

None of DY cards are even rare. This is a Vintage Pre War Forum. So when the question was asked about the High value list... DY's PSA 10's Never would of come to my mind...

* Not at all directed to Eric's answer... even though he started this mess

"Thanks Eric"

"Life is Soo Grand"

Originally Posted by ullmandds

Just my opinion...but...in no way shape or form do those former dimitri young cards belong in this discussion!

Maybe in a thread titled "stupidest money ever paid for an otherwise common card."