I am not sure what to think of this Ruth...

He states its a 1/1 which is misleading. Any chance this was the SGC A card?

[glchen]

This is indeed the same card that was sold in a Sterling Auction for roughly $4K as SGC Authentic here: Link. When I asked Brian about this card, he guessed that it was Authentic due to a very slight trim on the bottom edge. If you compare the photos from the Sterling auction to probstein's auction, you can see that it is the same card. Therefore, the card is a 1/1 because it is the "only" card in both the SGC and PSA pop reports.

[Peter_Spaeth]

Sometimes the crack-out game works out well.

[HRBAKER]

Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth

Sometimes the crack-out game works out well.

Yes, very Art Shellian don't you think.

[Leon]

So that card brought $3680 in the Sterling Auction. To me, that was a strong price for it in that grade (AUT). And I don't think the seller is doing anything really bad but that is just some asking price.....

Here are a few others with different backs but still similar-

Tharps-

http://www.ebay.com/itm/1928-Tharps-...item1e7473a802


and a Harringtons

http://www.ebay.com/itm/1928-Tharps-...item1e7473a802



.

[Shoeless Moe]

I'm surprised he doesn't have a Best Offer button.


So he wouldn't take $58,000 for it?

[Bocabirdman]

Originally Posted by Shoeless Moe

I'm surprised he doesn't have a Best Offer button.


So he wouldn't take $58,000 for it?

Couldn't it just simply be a finger-farted decimal point?

[theuclakid]

this seller primarily sells cards on consignment...as this one probably is....I have met and talked with Mr. Probstein at length, and I have found him to be intelligent and honest....I have had nothing but excellent service and communication from him...his listings dont waste words, that is true, and that can be refreshing....I highly recommend him...as to the cards value....who knows....the consignor in most cases dictates the buy it now price and probably has no clue, but does not want to chance the auction format....Bruce Perry