Goodwin lot #77 - J.L. Wilkinson?

[bmarlowe1]

This may have been discussed here before. I don't see how one can say with any certainty that this guy (below left) is J. L Wilkinson. The real Wilkinson is below center and right. The photo quality isn't good enough for me to do the kind of things I usually like to do, but we can see that the ear shape isn't right. What is the evidence that this guy is Wilkinson?

[Jaybird]

I agree. Funny that SGC, who is so loathe to slab cards with ID's which are clear and unmistakable, would take the chance on this one. I think this may be the case of a mistaken ID taken and being perpetuated. I believe I have seen other copies of this same PC with the same ID. I also agree it doesn't look like him to me.

[steve B]

I'm guessing there is or was some history to it? Maybe the original negative is out there with the ID?

Other than that I can't imagine trying to ID anyone from that example of the picture. It's nearly as bad as most bigfoot or UFO pics.

Steve B

[Runscott]

Mark, I'm attaching an image of the one I used to own, in case it helps. Wish I had higher-res, but this is it:

[Clutch-Hitter]

Did all those people have uni-brows, or does it just appear to be so?