Quote:
Originally Posted by barrysloate
Perhaps it is possible for a card in an 8 holder to be regraded a 10, but in the case of the Art Shell card in question it did not merit a 10 grade. Even from a scan there were minute flaws that could be easily detected with the naked eye.
So the issue isn't is it possible for an 8 to be regraded a 10, which I imagine in rare cases could happen, but why did that particular card receive a 10? That's the issue we've been debating.
|
Weak 10's are possible for PSA because PSA does not have the Pristine grade that SGC and Beckett have. Therefore, weak 10's are Gem Mint, and strong 10's are Pristine.
For the Art Shell card in question, that's obviously a misgrade and does not deserve a 10.
11-02-2012, 11:21 AM
Hybrid Mode
