FS Mantle, Aaron, Mays

[Big Six]

David...while I tend to agree with your analysis of the card (at least based on the scan provided) I also agree with Brian in that your pointing out the flaws (as you see them) and rationale for why you are offering what you're offering will also impact what others might offer for the card. To be fair, posting that in the thread versus sending a message to Sean offline would seemingly only have the result of shrinking the pool of potential buyers or at least putting Sean at a negative bargaining position considering your are a pretty respected member on the board (in my eyes at least). If you and Sean negotiate off line, then the onus is on Sean to either accept/reject your appraisal of the card. Now, I'm sure some folks are going to use your assessment against Sean and he's likely not going to get what he could have out of the card. I don't have a dog in this race but if that was my card, I'd be a little bent that you posted that. Hopefully you take this post in the neutral and non-antagogonistic spirit it was written...Matt