FS Mantle, Aaron, Mays

[peachlander]

hi-interested in the red heart mick(6.5)-what are you asking/and or wanting to trade-thanks-peachlander

[Wymers Auction]

Kirk could you post what you want for the cards please? Great cards by the way.

[vintagetoppsguy]

I would be interested in making you a fair offer on the '62 Aaron, but it would be based on the condition of the card, not what the flip says. Sorry, but there is no way that card is NM+, I don't care what BVG says. A lot of white is showing on those top two corners. It looks more Ex/Mt to me and my offer would be in the ballpark of an Ex/Mt card. Let me know if you're interested.

[Taxman]

Originally Posted by Wymers Auction

Kirk could you post what you want for the cards please? Great cards by the way.

PM sent...Thanks

[Taxman]

55Bowman Aaron is sold
52Bowman Mays will be in the next Sterling auction.

Thanks for the interest.

[shammus]

David and everyone, as a friendly reminder, please remember to keep your comments about someone else's listing to yourself if they are negative and/or carry the potential to interfere in the seller's listing. Nothing personal, I just want everyone to have a fair chance to co-exist in a positive environment on BST.

Thanks,
Brian

[pawpawdiv9]

Now, these are the type of cards i like to see. Amazing pieces.

[peterose4hof]

Originally Posted by shammus

David and everyone, as a friendly reminder, please remember to keep your comments about someone else's listing to yourself if they are negative and/or carry the potential to interfere in the seller's listing. Nothing personal, I just want everyone to have a fair chance to co-exist in a positive environment on BST.

Thanks,
Brian

Thanks for you efforts Brian. I agree that these types of comments don't belong in this section.

FWIW, I think the card is worthy of the grade; although a better scan might help.

[vintagetoppsguy]

Originally Posted by shammus

David and everyone, as a friendly reminder, please remember to keep your comments about someone else's listing to yourself if they are negative and/or carry the potential to interfere in the seller's listing. Nothing personal, I just want everyone to have a fair chance to co-exist in a positive environment on BST.

Thanks,
Brian

Brian,

I understand what you're saying, but it wasn't a negative comment and I wasn't trying to interfere in the seller's listing. It was a serious offer to buy based on the condition of the card. What's wrong with that? My only point was that there is no way that is a NM+ card and just because BVG says it is, doesn't make it so.

Here is a '62 Topps Musial in NM condition (supposedly half a grade lower than the Aaron). I think anybody would agree that the Musial is nicer than the Aaron. I can show you other examples of NM '62s that look just like the Musial.

Don't get me wrong, the Aaron is a nice card and I would love to have it in my collection and my offer still stands to buy it at an Ex/Mt price - the true condition that I believe the Aaron to be. And I agree with Chris's comments that it could just be the scan. If so, the seller should re-scan it to show it's true beauty. If that is the case, I would certainly pay a NM+ price, but my original offer to buy was based on the scan shown above.

[shammus]

David,

Our rules are pretty clear on this. Your comment is critical of the card and has no place on the board as it is on the negative side and other prospective buyers may be influenced by your opinion. This sort of commentary may affect the sellers ability to sell the card, which is not allowed on our forum.

I understand your reasoning and desire to haggle in this case, however I would ask that next time you take it offline and send the seller a note directly so that other potential buyers aren't influenced. Much appreciated,

Brian