ML Baseball Awards for 2012

[chaddurbin]

Originally Posted by Jlighter

I consider MVP to mean the most valuable player on their team, Miggy fits that definition perfectly.

is a guy more valuable to his team if he can only hit? or if he can hit, run, and play defense? like kevin durant is the best offensive player in the nba, but is he more valuable than lebron james who can score, pass, and play defense?

[novakjr]

Originally Posted by chaddurbin

is a guy more valuable to his team if he can only hit? or if he can hit, run, and play defense? like kevin durant is the best offensive player in the nba, but is he more valuable than lebron james who can score, pass, and play defense?

don't forget be an all out douche!!!

[barrysloate]

Bryce Harper got the ROY after all. Most of us missed that one.

[Runscott]

Originally Posted by barrysloate

Bryce Harper got the ROY after all. Most of us missed that one.

It's almost like all-star voting: the masses vote in the guys who get the most media attention - as such, they undoubtedly would have voted for Harper. But knowledgeable guys like you wouldn't.

[novakjr]

I think the question asked in the first place was who "should" win the awards.

I don't think we all necessarily missed it, as opposed to, it's not really what the question was..

We all gave honest answers, and I think a few of us even specified that Bryce's hype could win him the award, despite maybe not being most deserving..

[barrysloate]

Good point David.

[Runscott]

you're right. If I might have offended anyone with my (what I thought was) an innocent evaluation, I'll go back and delete it.

Scott <=== back on his eggshells.