Some advice needed about Musial's signature

[Mr. Zipper]

Originally Posted by maniac_73

Am I the only one who thinks this is a terrible way to treat the man at this point in his life?

Well, it does sound ghastly when presented in that way. But who knows... maybe Stan wants to keep signing to stay active in some way and/or to provide his family with additional income.

[isaac2004]

Originally Posted by Mr. Zipper

Well, it does sound ghastly when presented in that way. But who knows... maybe Stan wants to keep signing to stay active in some way and/or to provide his family with additional income.

I hope this isn't a John Henry Williams situation where the family grossly abuses the wants of an elderly man for profit.

[jgmp123]

Originally Posted by isaac2004

I hope this isn't a John Henry Williams situation where the family grossly abuses the wants of an elderly man for profit.

I follow his son on twitter because he often posts updates about his father, but lately all the messages are about him signing...I really hope it isn't the case...

[Lordstan]

I was in a very similar situation recently, but with Muhammad Ali. His signature has deteriorated very dramatically over time due to his Parkinson's. I had a Sport Magazine signed by Bobby Hull, Koufax, Mantle, Jim Brown, Bill Russell, and Willie Mays. It was missing Ali and Unitas. I went back and forth about getting Ali, because of the signature and the price.
I agree with Mike Navarro that there isn't a personal connection with a mail away item and so I decided to go for it, despite the sig quality. My lovely wife got me the sig as a Christmas gift.
While the sig is small, I am happy with it.



Given the cost is such a big part of your budget, I think Jim Stinson's idea makes a lot of sense.

[scmavl]

I'll make two points, which are related in my mind...

1. Having an item signed specifically FOR me (even though I'm simply sending it in with a check) makes it feel personal and much more special than something I bought on ebay. This is why I've never once thought of selling my Musial signed RC.

2. I wanted to get Killebrew's RC signed and was going to send it in with the $60 fee when I sent a donation to his organization but I decided to wait. (I probably blew that $60 on some modern crap) When I heard he was sick and thought "I'd better send this in NOW!", it was too late. He was no longer signing.

Yes, I could buy a signed Killebrew on ebay but it would never feel personal like the Musial does.

Food for thought...

[Cfern023]

delete

[Cfern023]

Originally Posted by jgmp123

I follow his son on twitter because he often posts updates about his father, but lately all the messages are about him signing...I really hope it isn't the case...

Originally Posted by isaac2004

I hope this isn't a John Henry Williams situation where the family grossly abuses the wants of an elderly man for profit.

John Henry Williams died of cancer in 04, Ted Williams son right?

Who was it you were talking about issac, curious?

Edit: I think it was Musials son, sorry.

[mr2686]

Sorry I'm late to the party but I just saw this. From my experience, I would not send it in to be signed. I have mentioned before that I sent in an early 70's 3000 hit Sports Ill already signed by Aaron, and Musials sig came back extreamely poor. It's framed in my hallway and it makes me quite sad to see his sig so bad after all the years of his strong penmenship. I would go the mat and frame route with a vintage sig like Jim suggested.

[7nohitter]

I was just looking at recent signatures on ebay...they are HORRID! Not sure how Topps can even release this stuff (I know, I know).

If someone dug up Ruth's skeleton and put a sharpie in it it would produce better 'signatures' than what Musial is capable of these days....