Another amazing auction.....Poll....

[peterose4hof]

The first poll choice should be "real and spectacular" instead of "real and good."

[frankbmd]

Sellers other auctions all have exactly the same description and all are graded Mint 9 by AGS.

They are a 68 Topps Ryan rookie, a 67 Topps Mantle and a 68 Topps Mantle.

Does this change anyone's mind? All good or all bad

[jimq]

I think on the real ones, there's a pronounced difference in the color of the orange/red background and the area where "big league chewing gum" is printed. On the card in question, it doesn't look like there's much difference in those 2 colors.

I would stay away, but it's amazing how many people wish for something to be real. My father in law does it all the time.

[terjung]

Without the description or the holder, I would have voted that it was probably authentic. I have no reason to doubt the seller, though, since I'm only looking at scans.

If the fakes are getting that good, that's pretty scary. It'd be interesting to see the card stock on it.

[Matthew H]

Coaches Corner sells AGS grades cards:

http://www.myccsa.com/lot/223/1933-g...aded-ex-5.aspx

'nuff said.

[GoldenAge50s]

I disagree on the bleed-thru. Don't confuse the white scanner space on the left as part of the left border. Left border is thin--right border wider. When viewing the reverse it is the opposite, as it should be!

Having said that, all 4 cards are counterfeits.

[Runscott]

Originally Posted by GoldenAge50s

I disagree on the bleed-thru. Don't confuse the white scanner space on the left as part of the left border. Left border is thin--right border wider. When viewing the reverse it is the opposite, as it should be!

Having said that, all 4 cards are counterfeits.

Yeah, I know. And it doesn't line up correctly.

[ctownboy]

Look at the Feed Back history. This person has sold PSA graded cards in the past so why not get these cards graded by PSA if they are authentic?

Also, the seller received a Negative back in 2009 for a PSA graded Clemente rookie. The buyer said the card was a fake put into a real PSA holder.

David

[glynparson]

I dont think it looks real to me. I believe it is 100% A FAKE.

[Leon]

At over 1k I hope it was real!! The winning bidder having private feedback doesn't inspire a lot of confidence....but it looks like there were other legit bidders bidding quite high.