Impressions of Goodwin Results

[MVSNYC]

nice wins John! i was the underbidder on the proof...glad it's going into your collection.

[terjung]

The color on that Bates proof is incredible! Congrats!

[tbob]

I'm going to kick myself for not bidding just one more time on the E94 olive Cobb but my bid plus the juice would have put it around $1800 and that's a lot for an authentic even if the card is nice. Besides the buyer probably would have come right back with another bid. Whoever won it just wore me out, every time I bid, he bid. Boom, boom, boom. The winner was probably prepared to go up in to the 2ks so I'll lick my wounds. Still need the olive and the violet Cobbs to complete the 6 color variation of the Cobbs. I think that thread about authentic vs. SGC 10, and how most went with the 10 might have played a part in my pulling back

[tbob]

John- that Bates proof is a stunner. If I am not mistaken, I bid on and barely got nosed out on that same card about 20 years ago in an online auction from Virginia. Went for a lot less then though...
tbob

[packs]

Those W600s went for a lot of money. Paper loss on the front and still up to $500. Glad I picked up my Donlin for the same price without the paper loss.

[philliesphan]

For the handful of you that said the Brown Lenox looked like a bargain, are you referring to the Frank Smith PSA 1 Brown Lenox?

I was the underbidder on the McQuillan, and just couldn't justify a $6+K bid for an Authentic card because of the rare back. But that one did close nearly $700- higher than the Frank Smith PSA 1.

Oh well -- no wins for me!