Beckett to SCG

[ANOMALY]

I always stick to PSA and/or SGC but on occasion a card I want is in a Beckett Holder ... Now I have been around the block a few times ... I bought a 1951 Mays Bowman (ex) and a 1920 Ruth W522 (vg) .... based on my eye - both cards are graded spot on, in fact my Mays card could have been a ex+ ... As far as the strip card - it measures up and has very nice borders. Because it WAS in a Beckett Holder, I was able to bargain down the price a bit ... Therefore I am of the opinion that you use your experience and not who graded it - to a point. Beyond PSA and SGC and then to Beckett there is no other grading company that I would buy unless I was able to inspect the card. All other holders I treat as if I am buying a raw card ... Anyone have an exception to the big 2 and then Beckett as a #3

[tiger8mush]

Originally Posted by ANOMALY

Anyone have an exception to the big 2 and then Beckett as a #3

CSG (or are they CGC?) is getting some love

[refz]

I only submit to SGC but buy both PSA & SGC. I really don’t buy or submit to anything else. As stated above if I were to buy CSG or Beckett I’d treat as if raw. I may have to bite the bullet and submit a few on card autos to Beckett because there is no way in hell I’m using PSA and waiting a second lifetime for the return.

Anyways back to the grading, I’m in your corner I really hope your grades transfer the same but I doubt it.

Danny