New BODA thread; PWCC selling previously outed cards now "reviewed by PSA"

[frankrizzo29]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

I am not one to defend PWCC, but when they send someone else’s card back to PSA, who blesses their own earlier negligence and then sends the card back to PWCC, what is PWCC to do? They should not have to buy and destroy the card. It belongs to someone else. And, if that someone else choses to keep it in, and sell the card from, the vault, all PWCC can do is disclose the fact that PSA re-reviewed and re-approved the card and the grade. Is the FBI going to confiscate the card bc BODA says it’s altered but PSA says it’s not? No... unless PSA is the subject of the investigation, which apparently it is not.

PSA is the bad guy here. They are the “experts” who can’t do their job right the first time, and then double down on their mistakes by approving the mistake; hell, the “experts” at PSA can’t tell a clear 1914 CJ reprint, with perforated borders, from the real McCoy. In this case, PSA is the problem, not PWCC. PSA is a dirty shop, plain and simple. And that won’t change. “Never get Cheated”

Ryan Hotchkiss

+1000

This hobby is too dependent on TPG's to slab cards, which in turn converts pieces of cardboard into a commodity that can be easily bought and sold. This will be a never ending debate until there is a proven TPG that has never graded an altered card and that the hobby/collectors trust.