I Think I've been scammed (Update to prior post)

[swarmee]

You don't need to deal with the original seller directly at all. Not sure why you're chasing that lead unless you know they intentionally mailed it to someone else.

If you want eBay to pay out on your claim (and then give up the card), then just file a Not Received claim, the seller will show tracking shows it's delivered, and you'll have to escalate to a manager (most likely) to show that the card is/was being offered for sale by another eBay member. If you don't want eBay to shoulder the cost (because they shouldn't), contact the post office and claim the insurance. If it was uninsured or underinsured, I guess go back to the eBay claim.

If you still want the card, you need to submit a police report for stolen goods, and provide them the new eBay seller information. Or try to work it out with the seller directly, but they should definitely be outed for selling stolen goods. And really, you should want the card. It looks great for the grade, and you got it for a great price (seller to you must have taken a loss based on the March 28th sale through Probstein).