Opinions if this card exists - E254 Colgan's Owen Wilson from Indianapolis

[brianp-beme]

Originally Posted by rhettyeakley

There is no Wilson for Indianapolis but right next to him in the alphabetical checklist is Williams for Indianapolis so I think something is amiss with the population report.

I think Rhett has unearthed the reason behind this phantom Wilson...just a long ago clerical error.

Brian

[pbspelly]

this Owen Wilson?

[chris122868]

Rhett Yeakley thanks for your response. I agree with you but PSA says it has graded 6 and I have told them they are mistaken but they insist they have not made a mistake 6 times. They say one is even registered and when they contact this person for a picture they do not reply and they say he could have passed away. I have told them the easiest way to confirm this is take it out and if someone has it they will send a picture which they will never see as it does not exist. How would you go about getting this changed in your opinion. I have even asked them to do a little research as I have to show that an Owen Wilson never played for Indianapolis not just during these years 1909 - 1911 but ever. I feel they are not really researching and for me to prove a card does not exist when it doesn't is tough ? Thanks for any help you can give me.

[obcmac]

They don't list the card on their own official checklist either, so here is another vote for DNE/clerical error.

[Leon]

Agreed on it probably being a clerical error. Sometimes those things can take on lives of their own.