BBCE 1952 Topps Wax Pack "Brick"

[Republicaninmass]

Ridiculous. Your control group is skewed.

People don't list poor condition $1 commons as singles on ebay, but a poor high number gets $40. The juice has to be worth the squeeze.

You wasted hours of your life on this trying to prove what? People are just over paying for high numbers? Go walk around a show like I do and ask every dealer. They don't come around, and they sell quickly

Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk

[toppcat]

Originally Posted by Republicaninmass

Ridiculous. Your control group is skewed.

People don't list poor condition $1 commons as singles on ebay, but a poor high number gets $40. The juice has to be worth the squeeze.

You wasted hours of your life on this trying to prove what? People are just over paying for high numbers? Go walk around a show like I do and ask every dealer. They don't come around, and they sell quickly

Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk

Not a waste at all Ted, I got to remind myself what a #ucking nitwit you are.

[Republicaninmass]

Originally Posted by toppcat

Not a waste at all Ted, I got to remind myself what a *ucking nitwit you are.

I'm sure when your parents watched you in marching band, they swore up and down you were the only one who was "in step".

Any other experiments or pipedreams Dr Stranglove that I can simply poke a hole in?

I just wish you'd waited until I sold off all my high numbers before the radical change in thought amongst buyers.


Walk into a show, let me know how many you find. Ask dealers how long they last when they are in the case. It must just be a frenzy based on 65 years of rumors.

[mckinneyj]

As a collector or 52Ts I find myself in Ted's camp. The 52 semi-high commons can frequently be found in lots along with lower numbered cards without any special mention on ebay. Any lots with highs included are sure to advertise as such. Vendors at card shows have trouble finding or keeping any high series cards. Semi-highs are easily found at shows. I think the price differential between the high and semi-high series is an accurate reflection of the relative populations. Just my observation/experience...

[toppcat]

Originally Posted by mckinneyj

As a collector or 52Ts I find myself in Ted's camp. The 52 semi-high commons can frequently be found in lots along with lower numbered cards without any special mention on ebay. Any lots with highs included are sure to advertise as such. Vendors at card shows have trouble finding or keeping any high series cards. Semi-highs are easily found at shows. I think the price differential between the high and semi-high series is an accurate reflection of the relative populations. Just my observation/experience...

I think the spread is accurate to a point, there is some type of "legendary" status kicker working with the highs as well. I did the canvass as I have never really seen a comparison of the semi and high series anywhere, so it was instructive and I figured I could get a blog post out of it as well. I thought there would be less highs than I found. 60 of #368 surprised me for sure.

[sflayank]

Just look at the pop report
Every card from 100 to 407 with the exception of mantle May's berra feller ..the same pop
500-60] cards of each approx...
That's over 50000 hi#s graded
Probably 250000 not graded
Rare? Hmmm

[toppcat]

Originally Posted by sflayank

Just look at the pop report
Every card from 100 to 407 with the exception of mantle May's berra feller ..the same pop
500-60] cards of each approx...
That's over 50000 hi#s graded
Probably 250000 not graded
Rare? Hmmm

Yup. In demand vs rare.

[toppcat]

Originally Posted by Republicaninmass

I'm sure when your parents watched you in marching band, they swore up and down you were the only one who was "in step".

Any other experiments or pipedreams Dr Stranglove that I can simply poke a hole in?

I just wish you'd waited until I sold off all my high numbers before the radical change in thought amongst buyers.


Walk into a show, let me know how many you find. Ask dealers how long they last when they are in the case. It must just be a frenzy based on 65 years of rumors.

Have a nice day Ted.

[Jason19th]

Originally Posted by Republicaninmass

Ridiculous. Your control group is skewed.

People don't list poor condition $1 commons as singles on ebay, but a poor high number gets $40. The juice has to be worth the squeeze.

You wasted hours of your life on this trying to prove what? People are just over paying for high numbers? Go walk around a show like I do and ask every dealer. They don't come around, and they sell quickly

Sent from my SM-N950U using Tapatalk

As some who
Is putting together a low grade 52 set I disagree. Lots of people list lots of low condition commons as singles. Also, poor condition highs go for much more then 40

[samosa4u]

The sad part about this hobby is that almost everybody believes the bullsh*t that gets fed to them. There are very few of us who challenge commonly held beliefs. Toppcat's post shows that there is nothing special about the high numbers and I thought this all along. There are plenty of em' out there for everyone!

Let's look at the 1951 Bowmans - same sh*t. When I started taking interest in this set, I would research online and read things like "high numbers are scarce! Very tough high numbers! High numbers are more difficult to find!" Well, let's do a quick eBay search from Canada, shall we?

#1 Whitey Ford (57)
#2 Yogi Berra (29)
#3 Robin Roberts (30)

#305 Willie Mays (39)
#306 Jim Piersall (26)
#307 Walt Masterson (50)

Hmmmm ...