Poppage! But wait...there's more!

[arexcrooke]

And with it the bad news of a card that has been trimmed. The seller I bought it from is on ebay and I will be contacting him soon. Btw this was on the CC Renew CC subscription vouchers.
So, the question I have is this: If the seller is not agreeable to a return with a refund can I still go the PayPal claim route? The card is significantly not as described.
And to throw another couple of kinks in the hose:
1-Another card I submitted from them came back as Min-Size not met
2-Another card that I didnt submit was called an EX, the front might have been close but the back was 100-0 centered. I figured I would just eat it ($60 card) but now I am of the mind to work on a refund for it as well.

So, in essence what would you do and what options do I have available to me?

Thanks,
Arex