T206 Orevall

[BigBeerGut]

Real or Fake?
Any help is aprectd!

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Don't know why you'd fake this in such terrible condition does someone need $15 that badly? That being said, the corners look ground down the black border around the picture bothers me, and the overall flatness of the color on the front is weird. The back looks good lol.

[Bill77]

Fake. That card should have either a 350 or 460 back not a 150 back.

[Jobu]

Good catch Bill. EDIT: To be real it would have to be a rebacked card, but the wear isn't right and the colors on the back look off too.

Originally Posted by Bill77

Fake. That card should have either a 350 or 460 back not a 150 back.

[Luke]

Agreed that its an impossible combo, but I also think the entire thing is fake.

[Huysmans]

Definitely fake....
as there is no "Orevall" card in the T206 set.

[Jobu]

Took a closer look and I agree with this actually, so I am going to change my earlier post.

Originally Posted by Luke

Agreed that its an impossible combo, but I also think the entire thing is fake.

[bbcard1]

Agreed. It's almost certainly good in terms of authencity and bad in terms of condition.

[Sean]

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards

Don't know why you'd fake this in such terrible condition does someone need $15 that badly? That being said, the corners look ground down the black border around the picture bothers me, and the overall flatness of the color on the front is weird. The back looks good lol.

Agreed that it can't be real, but I like Scott's point: why go to this much effort to fake a nothing card?

[CobbSpikedMe]

Originally Posted by Sean

Agreed that it can't be real, but I like Scott's point: why go to this much effort to fake a nothing card?

Practice?

[RCMcKenzie]

Overall would have been a popular player and a nice card to have at the time. He had 3 cards in the "T206 set". He led the NL in strikeouts and shutouts in 1909. Injury cut short his career. The back is not known as a 150 as y'all have pointed out.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by CobbSpikedMe

Practice?

LOL....but maybe true!

[trdcrdkid]

Originally Posted by Sean

Agreed that it can't be real, but I like Scott's point: why go to this much effort to fake a nothing card?

The person who beat it up isn’t necessarily the same person who created a fake. I have a 1974 Fleer Pioneers of Baseball card that somebody deliberately folded and beat up, presumably because that assumed that it was a really old card and that old cards “should” look like that. This could be a reprint that some unsophisticated person best up to make it look more “authentic”.

[Leon]

I don't think it's an authentic reprint. It is a fake reprint. And "Overall" it's still a yucky looking card.

Originally Posted by trdcrdkid

The person who beat it up isn’t necessarily the same person who created a fake. I have a 1974 Fleer Pioneers of Baseball card that somebody deliberately folded and beat up, presumably because that assumed that it was a really old card and that old cards “should” look like that. This could be a reprint that some unsophisticated person best up to make it look more “authentic”.

[steve B]

Originally Posted by trdcrdkid

The person who beat it up isn’t necessarily the same person who created a fake. I have a 1974 Fleer Pioneers of Baseball card that somebody deliberately folded and beat up, presumably because that assumed that it was a really old card and that old cards “should” look like that. This could be a reprint that some unsophisticated person best up to make it look more “authentic”.

I didn't get many of those as a kid. Only one store in town had them, and it was pretty far from my neighborhood.

I did pick up one or two at school, but they all had that sort of damage. They just didn't fit well in most kids pockets.