T205 "Rehel" Oaks- Which Do You Prefer?

[Leon]

Trying to decide which of these to keep. For this exercise we we'll say the backs are equal. This is what happens when you are a collector trying to do a presentable set. I said I was going to quit the upgrade game but it's so fun.

[sb1]

The one on the right for me.

[Cozumeleno]

One on the right for me. I prefer the border color of the one on the left but it looks like it has a few more flaws.

[sterlingfox]

Definitely the one on the left for me - much sharper, better registered image than the one on the right.

[pherbener]

I like the one on the left. The other one seems too washed out for me.

[tschock]

The one on the left. I prefer better registration and color than cleaner borders. It is similar to buy the card (player), not the holder (border).

[Cat]

The one on the Right seems to have those "far away eyes." I voted for the other one.

[T205 GB]

One on the right for me. Considering your set the right one should in just based on the left one having a crease and more boarder issues

[MVSNYC]

Originally Posted by sterlingfox

Definitely the one on the left for me - much sharper, better registered image than the one on the right.

This.

[Aquarian Sports Cards]

Originally Posted by Cozumeleno

One on the right for me. I prefer the border color of the one on the left but it looks like it has a few more flaws.

+1

And is that a wrinkle up from the bottom border?

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Aquarian Sports Cards

+1

And is that a wrinkle up from the bottom border?

It is a wrinkle but I should add I don't mind a small, inconsequential wrinkle. It's not a high grade set.

[Paul S]

Both scans being equal, the one on the right, - background color is brighter and sets off the portrait. Card on the left, registration is too off, for me.. (Not that I'm 'picky' or anything).

On the other hand...did you mean Rebel Oakes?

[bauce]

The one on the left has deeper color.
The one on the right has a better registry alignment.

I would go with the better alignment.

[commishbob]

I voted for the one on the left thinking 'well, this is close' but the more I look at them the more convinced I am that the left image is much superior. Richer colors, better details. It has a few more condition flaws but I think it's a beautiful example of the set.

[tiger8mush]

left

bolder colors (look at his hair), sharper image, and the borders seem to be ever so slightly larger than the one on the right

[Jacklitsch]

One on the right. The ding on the upper right corner of the one on the left bothers me.

BTW, it's Rebel.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Jacklitsch

One on the right. The ding on the upper right corner of the one on the left bothers me.

BTW, it's Rebel.

I was only going with the card. I knew it was Rebel. I put some exclamation marks up there to help albeit after the fact..... I'll say my thoughts on the 2, later. Interesting perspectives so far.

[slipk1068]

I voted for the one on the right. It is creases-free and looks cleaner. I do, however, like the fat borders on the one on the left.

[T206Collector]

It's funny - I guess beauty is in the eye of the beholder. I am shocked that anyone would choose the one on the left. I collect baseball cards, not photographs. I'll take sharp corners and no creases every day over a slightly deeper/focused registration.

[Big Six]

The one on the right. The left is off register (see hat) and looks dirty. Better borders on the right, too!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[steve B]

They're slightly different, so I'd keep both.

[brianp-beme]

The one on the left...the blank stare and facial coloration of the one on the right makes Mr. Oakes look like he has an upcoming appointment with the mortician.

Brian

[darwinbulldog]

I'll say left. Right looks seasick, though I probably only notice that because they're displayed side-by-side.

[Paul S]

Ditch'm both and get a third!