You ever have an auto that you know is genuine

[pbspelly]

because you witnessed it being signed, and yet others say it's fake? Curious how often this happens

[packs]

I have. I posted this Sandy Koufax autograph I obtained in person at Spring Training two years ago and people said if I hadn't said I got this signature myself, they would have thought it was no good. However, in my personal experience this is the most authentic Koufax that exists:

[packs]

Here's a Bryce Harper that gets looks too. Also got this one at Spring Training:

[Bpm0014]

Story told a couple of times: I have a Michael Jordan signed Bulls jersey. Signed in front of me, along with a rookie card and an 8x10 and a basketball and a baseball. My uncle did bodyguard work for him so I had access to him for years. After 10+ years, I decide to sell the jersey and basketball last year. The ball passes, the jersey doesn't. Signed in front of me...

[Runscott]

I suspect that this personally-obtained Mike Schmidt autograph would not pass scrutinization of many Net54 members:

[theshleps]

2 IP Ichiros failed the first time, passed the 2nd time

[w7imel]

Originally Posted by pbspelly

because you witnessed it being signed, and yet others say it's fake? Curious how often this happens

I had a Muhammad Ali signed baseball removed by ebay years ago and iI personally handed him the ball at a little league baseball game and watched him sign it. Strange