Love of the game auctions......1956 Mantle Number 135 PSA 8.5

[russkcpa]

Looks like this will go far below market value


http://loveofthegameauctions.com/Stu...-LOT16070.aspx


Also Memory Lane .... see later post

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by russkcpa

Looks like this will go far below market value


http://loveofthegameauctions.com/Stu...-LOT16070.aspx

Your card?

[Rich Falvo]

I'm sure the current high bidder appreciates you pointing this out.

[russkcpa]

Originally Posted by bnorth

Your card?

Here's my card if you want it
$14,500

And it's NOT up for auction

[russkcpa]

Originally Posted by Rich Falvo

I'm sure the current high bidder appreciates you pointing this out.

Have you seen what PSA 8's go for on PWCC auctions ?
8.5 pretty rare and much more valuable
JMHO

[russkcpa]

Here is another at Memory Lane.
The Love of The Game PSA 8.5 looks much nicer
MY SGC 92 looks better than both of those PSA 8.5's

https://memorylaneinc.com/site/bids/...e?itemid=47987

[RedsFan1941]

so what if it is his card? He posted in the correct section, and others routinely link to items they have at auction. not to mention that card could use the help.

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by RedsFan1941

so what if it is his card? He posted in the correct section, and others routinely link to items they have at auction. not to mention that card could use the help.

It got moved here from the main page. I would not have asked if it was his card if it was posted in the correct section.

[Bicem]

All 3 are beauties! I think the LOTG one will probably get more bids as it's a steal right now.

[RedsFan1941]

Originally Posted by bnorth

It got moved here from the main page. I would not have asked if it was his card if it was posted in the correct section.

ah, got it thanks for clarifying.

[bobbyw8469]

Hard to say...this is one of those cards that got bumped like overnight. One day in 2014, it's like someone flipped the switch and said "This isn't a $5,000 card anymore....this is a $15,000 card"....Did the "buyer's group" do that?? Who knows....maybe 6 months down to line, people will realize that they overpaid and be hoping and wishing they can get $10,000 for theirs.

[Republicaninmass]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

Hard to say...this is one of those cards that got bumped like overnight. One day in 2014, it's like someone flipped the switch and said "This isn't a $5,000 card anymore....this is a $15,000 card"....Did the "buyer's group" do that?? Who knows....maybe 6 months down to line, people will realize that they overpaid and be hoping and wishing they can get $10,000 for theirs.

I've been hoping the same for the 52 topps for 20 years, and it ain't happened!

[Leon]

Originally Posted by RedsFan1941

ah, got it thanks for clarifying.

Some clarification-
The thread was moved WITHOUT a redirect because it shouldn't have been there in the first place AND looked like (regardless of if it was or not) someone was trying to get exposure in a manner not suitable for the front page. A redirect (link to the thread moved) can be from 0 hours to eternity. They are usually set for around 1-4 hours then the redirect goes away and the thread stays where it was moved. The longer the redirect stays the more exposure the moved thread gets.

[JustinD]

Originally Posted by bobbyw8469

Hard to say...this is one of those cards that got bumped like overnight. One day in 2014, it's like someone flipped the switch and said "This isn't a $5,000 card anymore....this is a $15,000 card"....Did the "buyer's group" do that?? Who knows....maybe 6 months down to line, people will realize that they overpaid and be hoping and wishing they can get $10,000 for theirs.

Agreed.

And while I am not calling out the post as wrong when put in the proper area or context, having to try to support a value by attempting to draw up other sales vs letting the market dictate does not support a strong argument toward value.